[Cherry Christmas]

No matter what he doesn't deserve what Gary did to him last week, he was very patronising. Okay he is not as good as many of the singers on there but he is a lot more likable than Hannah or Tamera.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Cherie

No matter what he doesn't deserve what Gary did to him last week, he was very patronising. Okay he is not as good as many of the singers on there but he is a lot more likable than Hannah or Tamera.

I feel sorry for him for being picked in the first place, Louis could have picked someone or many many people who were goodlooking but could also sing, but they want a few punchbags in there. This is why I prefer the Voice (I don't care how many people hate it )

[Cherry Christmas]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I feel sorry for him for being picked in the first place, Louis could have picked someone or many many people who were goodlooking but could also sing, but they want a few punchbags in there. This is why I prefer the Voice (I don't care how many people hate it )

I don't know why Gary gets so sulky he was part of the process that put him through 2 auditions and bootcamp...

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Cherie

I don't know why Gary gets so sulky he was part of the process that put him through 2 auditions and bootcamp...

All for the drama I suppose

[Cherry Christmas]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

All for the drama I suppose

Yeah that's is it, but its so fake it annoys me.

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

Talk Talk are doing a q&a with Luke and Sam. Let's see if someone asks abotu this.

[Headie]

Originally Posted by Cherie

I don't know why Gary gets so sulky he was part of the process that put him through 2 auditions and bootcamp...

Actually Gary said no @ the auditions and Louis had the final decisions for the boys at bootcamp. So Gary wanted him gone the whole time

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

Originally Posted by Hayden

Actually Gary said no @ the auditions and Louis had the final decisions for the boys at bootcamp. So Gary wanted him gone the whole time

Oh yeah, i remember that.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Cherie

No matter what he doesn't deserve what Gary did to him last week, he was very patronising. Okay he is not as good as many of the singers on there but he is a lot more likable than Hannah or Tamera.

I 100% agree, Gary was in my view really patronising, also if Sam Callahan can play the guitar,( and Luke has been playing his and also Abi playing the piano), then why shouldn't be allowed to play it.

This is what I don't get with X Factor, they say it has to be more than just a voice, that you have to have other things rather than just be able to sing.
He can sing, okay he hasn't,on his own admission, the strongest voice but he is in tune and he has personality,is likeable and has a really good attitude even in the face of the most unfair and harsh criticism from Gary, whose own solo career didn't exactly go great.

Being able to play his guitar would actually maybe also show another side of his versatility and may even add confidence to his voice as it certainly does Luke's too.
Luke is really at home and in his element with his guitar.

Sadly, more and more, X Factor by its daft themes and the song lists they have to choose from, actually even more now stifles any talent an act has rather than enhance it and bring it out week after week.