[RodHull]

Originally Posted by erinp5

mark took it for his salon .
Ash also took it to split with the group ,but that was already decide by all ,he only needed to say NO ,Winston /Helen /Pav/Christopher did .

I think the point was they had discussed it earlier with Chris when he had hinted he wouldn't split it or gave that impression, Ash believed if Chris or Ashleigh won they wouldnt split it and its likely Ashleigh will win they all know that.

[erinp5]

Originally Posted by RodHull

I think the point was they had discussed it earlier with Chris when he had hinted he wouldn't split it or gave that impression, Ash believed if Chris or Ashleigh won they wouldnt split it and its likely Ashleigh will win they all know that.

so Ash like Chris and Mark broke the pact ,I understand the reasons but the fact remain three HMs broke the pact ,different reason but the same outcome .

[RodHull]

Originally Posted by erinp5

so Ash like Chris and Mark broke the pact ,I understand the reasons but the fact remain three HMs broke the pact ,different reason but the same outcome .

Semantics... yes technically they all broke the pact the pact was stupid anyway what should be looked as is the intentions behind it.

Mark - selfish but self conscious enough to share SOME of it. He is a liar though came out looking bad, he has form in this area though (putting Ash up for eviction then lying about it)

Ash - Doesnt trust certain other HMs to split the money (Ashleigh/Chris/Pav) I would argue with good reason, we'll never know if he would have but I think he would personally.

Chris - His reasoning was bull**** piled onto bull****, first he made out it was some selfless act where he would show how greedy they all are (while still getting the 15k himself how honorable of him) then he said hed just share it with his mates then he lied to everyone and said he was gonna split it with all of them. Then has the cheek to go to the DR and do one of his 'rants' (which his mate told him everyone loves btw to put this into context) about how dissapointing it is that they all reacted like that and how sad it is on his high horse again.

HES ACTING HES PLAYING ALL OF YOU FOR MUGS INCLUDING PRINCESS ASHLEIGH

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by MrWong

There's no defending any of them.

..there really isn't..words mean nothing/come easy..it's actions that are the only thing that are telling..oh, I would have split it with Ashleigh and Christopher...oh I would have just taken a little bit more for my salon..oh, I'll take it to make sure the pact is kept...just words/the actions of all of them were that they said yes and would take the money....the actions of the others by saying no was that they intended at that moment to keep the pact...

[MrWong]

Originally Posted by Ammi

..there really isn't..words mean nothing/come easy..it's actions that are the only thing that are telling..oh, I would have split it with Ashleigh and Christopher...oh I would have just taken a little bit more for my salon..oh, I'll take it to make sure the pact is kept...just words/the actions of all of them were that they said yes and would take the money....the actions of the others by saying no was that they intended at that moment to keep the pact...

Exactly. They are the only hm's anyone should be giving credit to.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Achilles

Ash and Mark took it for the exact same reason. Difference is that Chris was honest.
Ash and Mark wanted it for the cool kids gang only.

This ^

Also Helen and that lot don't know he said that just like they don't know Mark was planning on going back on the deal as well and only sharing some of it

[Livia]

I'm desperate for BB to show the diary room footage of Chris, Ash and Mark to the rest of the house. Especially Mark.

[Daffodil]

Chris had no intention of being magnanimous. Watch it over again and watch his sly, shifty expression when he says he will take it.

[HBB1508]

I do have to laugh - Chris is slated and called a liar and a snake for actually telling the truth but Ash and Mark get away scott free when they showed themselves to be utter liars - you couldn't make it up if you tried.

[Daffodil]

I think what it is is that people weren't surprised by Ash and Mark. But Chris was a different matter. A lot of people still think he is a kind and intelligent chap

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Livia

I'm desperate for BB to show the diary room footage of Chris, Ash and Mark to the rest of the house. Especially Mark.

I know Of course he would probably say I was only going to share it with Helen, Ash and Winston and they would forgive him