[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

Like I said, most of these self-proclaimed superfans are just armchair critics who are so convinced that they'll dominate the game based off of absolutely nothing, and then get in the house and are way over their heads because they're actually playing against people instead of living out some heroic fantasy where everyone else is a pawn to use at their disposal. Recruits are just as capable of playing great games and many superfans have played awful games.

I agree with this. Doesn't mean someone can't favor a superfan to a recruit beforehand because they like to see good gameplay over someone in there who doesn't know what they're doing.

Like I said, I personally like both. Raph's PRE-SHOW judgment rankings makes sense though... he shouldn't be bashed for that opinion.