[jaxie]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

i can't bear this awful smear campaign thats based on unfounded opinion rather than observation and fact....this is someones life you're attacking, not their game playing or their annoying personalty in the house ...its wrong..even if someone does have mental health issues that does not constitute this type of targeted abuse...no better than racism, sexism or homophobia...

I would personally question the mental health of the person who has set up this thread just as a negative tool to abuse someone that they believe to be vulnerable.....you should be ashamed

Fair enough lets not search for ways to justify how she acts and say then that Harry has no problems, deserves no sympathy and is just a vicious brat who has tantrums.

But actually its far nicer to search for an explanation that's more beyond her control to explain how she acts.

[REDCROP]

Originally Posted by jaxie

Fair enough lets not search for ways to justify how she acts and say then that Harry has no problems, deserves no sympathy and is just a vicious brat who has tantrums.

What sympathy ?...You haven't shown any...you're just behaving like a coward who's part of some sick little witch hunt aimed at giving a total stranger who's not here to defend themselves the stigma of mental illness....

Ever considered that your behaviour is not stable ? I find it deeply offensive and disgusting....AND very immature

[jaxie]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

What sympathy ?...You haven't shown any...you're just behaving like a coward who's part of some sick little witch hunt aimed at giving a total stranger who's not here to defend themselves the stigma of mental illness....

Ever considered that your behaviour is not stable ? I find it deeply offensive and disgusting....AND very immature

This isn't about me. And then if you ever read what I said instead of reacting you'd see its not witch hunty at all.

And targeting forum members is against the rules.

[REDCROP]

Originally Posted by jaxie

This isn't about me. And then if you ever read what I said instead of reacting you'd see its not witch hunty at all.

And targeting forum members is against the rules.

Who accused you of targeting forum members ? Seems you have your facts wrong.... i don't feel in the least bit targeted by this or in the least bit intimidated either....the person you are targeting isn't a forum member ...they aren't here to defend themselves

Im reacting to something i see as very improper and wrong...i aint targeting anybody..im merely defending someone who isn't here to defend themselves against accusations that are completely unfounded

[jaxie]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

Who accused you of targeting forum members ? Seems you have your facts wrong.... i don't feel in the least bit targeted by this or in the least bit intimidated either....the person you are targeting isn't a forum member ...they aren't here to defend themselves

Im reacting to something i see as very improper and wrong...i aint targeting anybody..im merely defending someone who isn't here to defend themselves against accusations that are completely unfounded

You are targeting me with personal remarks.

[vafunghoul]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

Who accused you of targeting forum members ? Seems you have your facts wrong.... i don't feel in the least bit targeted by this or in the least bit intimidated either....the person you are targeting isn't a forum member ...they aren't here to defend themselves

Im reacting to something i see as very improper and wrong...i aint targeting anybody..im merely defending someone who isn't here to defend themselves against accusations that are completely unfounded

That is your opinion.
But by that logic, ANY negative comments should be off limits since HG's aren't here to defend themselves.

The mere definition of an opinion and subjective interpretation is a conclusion that is unfounded. It's just a damn opinion. Is that so hard to comprehend? No one is diagnosing her.

[REDCROP]

Originally Posted by vafunghoul

That is your opinion.
But by that logic, ANY negative comments should be off limits since HG's aren't here to defend themselves.

The mere definition of an opinion and subjective interpretation is a conclusion that is unfounded. It's just a damn opinion. Is that so hard to comprehend? No one is diagnosing her.

you're correct any type of open criticism or negative opinion is what the show is open for and about...but not negative attacks on a persons disability....if she was blind or physically disabled you wouldn't dream of doing it so whats the difference....if you REALY believe she has a disability why on earth would you attack her and laugh at her for it ?

[abhorson]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

you're correct any type of open criticism or negative opinion is what the show is open for and about...but not negative attacks on a persons disability....if she was blind or physically disabled you wouldn't dream of doing it so whats the difference....if you REALY believe she has a disability why on earth would you attack her and laugh at her for it ?

Is it OK to call her mad

[vafunghoul]

Originally Posted by REDCROP

you're correct any type of open criticism or negative opinion is what the show is open for and about...but not negative attacks on a persons disability....if she was blind or physically disabled you wouldn't dream of doing it so whats the difference....if you REALY believe she has a disability why on earth would you attack her and laugh at her for it ?

I'm not laughing at her. I believe she needs help to resolve some issues.

We've all called someone crazy (and worse) while driving and getting cut off yes? It's an opinion on someone actions/behavior.