[user104658]

Originally Posted by Joseph the Carpenter

He is offering a solution to a menace, beit misguided or not

What other solutions are being offered?

The "solution" of not inadvertantly pushing thousands more young Muslims in the direction of radicalisation by turning them into boogeymen and pariahs?

"Other people aren't offering solutions to make it better" isn't really an excuse for actively making it worse, is it?

--

"Help help I've badly burned my hand on the cooker!!"

"Come here quick I'll pour this on it!"

*pppsssshhhh*

"AAAAAARRRGGGHHH My hand is melting! Melting to the bone!!! What was that???"

"It was highly concentrated hydrochloric acid..."

"WHAT??? WHY!? Help me I'm going to lose my hand! OH GOD the unbearable agony blllrrrgghhhh *gurgle*"

"*tut* Well, it might have been misguided but no one else was offering a solution were they? Sooorr-y for trying to help "