[Jack_]

This is a no brainer.

One format continues C5's obsession with ****ing celebrities, isn't even a civilian series and will begin the process CBB being the only version that survives, and the other is a fresh, daring new trial on a dying show.

If this is the last civilian series I'd much rather watch all civilians under a good consistent format than celebrities getting involved in whatever messy remains of a format we have now.