[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Withano

Youre not judging him on a clean slate though, youve made it clear how excited you are for his arrival when he, in your words, might be different.

Or does it only work one way

Not true. I've made it clear how excited I am for him to enter because the meltdowns will be hilarious, and I said to Marc that I think he'd be a good housemate. That's a keyword: think. I didn't say he would be, and if it turns out he isn't I'll want him out in just the same way I would anyone else, because I am consistent

Please don't put words into my mouth

Originally Posted by Braden

If you use that logic in the sense of liking a housemate before they enter an all-star season then it kind of seems a bit silly.

It's like someone saying 'I loved Jayne Connery on BB17, I can't wait to see her when she enters All-Stars', and then you saying 'well she might not be the same this time around so I think you should withold you 'preconception'. It doesn't make sense.

Well firstly I'd say this isn't an All Stars season so it's a pointless comparison, but if it was the same sentiment would stand. There's no reason why a housemate would be exactly the same in two series

Take this season of BBUS for example, I didn't want to see Nicole or James again and opposed them entering but decided to judge them on a clean slate because it happened after all and that's the point of the show. As it happens I like James more than I did last year and Nicole even less than BB16. Different season, different circumstances