[Shaun]

Come on now Jack, Cosmo would not be a worse winner than Scotty T or James Hill (I won't go into Jim Davidson) (not after that shirtlifter comment at Brian Dowling)

[Cherie]

Jedward, Kim or Nicola

Coleen, James C and Bianca would be just awful

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Come on now Jack, Cosmo would not be a worse winner than Scotty T or James Hill (I won't go into Jim Davidson) (not after that shirtlifter comment at Brian Dowling)

He really would, Scotty was a predictable MOTR winner that I did at least find mildly amusing on occasion and he had a storyline with Megan, James should never have won but I enjoyed the dynamic he had with Farrah and to an extent Austin (mind you I stopped watching that series early too), but Cosmo has literally done or said nothing in a series full of great characters and it'd be an incredibly disappointing end

[MB.]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Come on now Jack, Cosmo would not be a worse winner than Scotty T or James Hill (I won't go into Jim Davidson) (not after that shirtlifter comment at Brian Dowling)

Let alone saying that all of the above (plus Bear, Charlotte... even Paddy) are better than Ulrika, which I'm sure is against several treason laws?

[Ross.]

Would be fine with anyone that's not Bianca

Watch her win now

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by MB.

Let alone saying that all of the above (plus Bear, Charlotte... even Paddy) are better than Ulrika, which I'm sure is against several treason laws?

And Alex Reid

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by reece(:

And Alex Reid

Alex Reid is one of the more underrated winners, and his hilariously bizarre scenes with (the robbed) Stephen Baldwin are better than Ulrika's 'funny' performance and whatever else she supposedly did but didn't

Paddy's dynamic with Sally was way better also