[Amy Jade]

I've seen a lot of peoole saying the episode was great apart from the Rosita and Sasha road trip to kill Negan but for me that was easily my favourite part. I still love them both especially Rosita - one of my main annoyances sometimes with the show has been how quickly people get over deaths, yeah it is part of that world but imo seeing someone you love brutally killed would disturb the crap out of you.

Maggie has seen her Dad decapitated, her little sister with her brains blown out and her lover have his brain smashed in and she she's not even a bit messed up? Carl saw his mum die and cut a baby out of her and he's not a little disturbed? The only people who I think have been shown truly greiving have been Daryl (for Merle) Carol (for Sophia) and Rosita (for Abraham). I know death effects people differently but cmon!

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

I've seen a lot of peoole saying the episode was great apart from the Rosita and Sasha road trip to kill Negan but for me that was easily my favourite part. I still love them both especially Rosita - one of my main annoyances sometimes with the show has been how quickly people get over deaths, yeah it is part of that world but imo seeing someone you love brutally killed would disturb the crap out of you.

Maggie has seen her Dad decapitated, her little sister with her brains blown out and her lover have his brain smashed in and she she's not even a bit messed up? Carl saw his mum die and cut a baby out of her and he's not a little disturbed? The only people who I think have been shown truly greiving have been Daryl (for Merle) Carol (for Sophia) and Rosita (for Abraham). I know death effects people differently but cmon!

Also Rick for Lori plus I think Carl went a bit mental after Lori died

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Also Rick for Lori plus I think Carl went a bit mental after Lori died

I thought he just carried on pretty normally, admittedly I haven't watched that season for ages but I can't remember him being as upset as you'd expect.

I forgot Andra though tbf, she was messy after Amy died.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

I thought he just carried on pretty normally, admittedly I haven't watched that season for ages but I can't remember him being as upset as you'd expect.

I forgot Andra though tbf, she was messy after Amy died.

He went a bit crazy and was seeing her ghost everywhere

[Cal.]

Andrea's grief for Amy lasted the longest in the show I think. It lasted the rest of season one after Amy died all the way until the end of season 2.

[Cal.]

But timeline wise in the show that was only like 20 days.

[user104658]

Originally Posted by Cal.

But timeline wise in the show that was only like 20 days.

Nah it has to have been much longer than that, it was (at the very least) long enough for Carl to recover from a near-fatal gunshot wound to the stomach, which would have taken months...

[Cal.]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

Nah it has to have been much longer than that, it was (at the very least) long enough for Carl to recover from a near-fatal gunshot wound to the stomach, which would have taken months...

Amy died on Day 62 of the outbreak.
The group flee the farm on Day 82 of the outbreak.
Season 2 ends on Day 83 of the outbreak.

So 21 days between Amy's death and the end of season 2.

http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Th..._Show_Timeline

[user104658]

Originally Posted by Cal.

Amy died on Day 62 of the outbreak.
The group flee the farm on Day 82 of the outbreak.
Season 2 ends on Day 83 of the outbreak.

So 21 days between Amy's death and the end of season 2.

http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Th..._Show_Timeline

Then Carl = Wolverine

[Cal.]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

Then Carl = Wolverine

The show are really messy when it comes to wounds. Carl, Hershel and Carol have all recovered from severe injuries over a matter of days in the show.

Spoiler:

Which contradicts the fact they're having Rosita shot in the season finale so she can disappear for the first half of season 8 whilst Christian Serratos goes on maternity leave

[Cal.]

The whole Sasha thing feels exactly like the situation Andrea was in this time 4 years ago.

[Headie]

Ugh I actually hate Rick and co's mentality that they're the good guys when they just raided a completely innocent, off-the-radar group and stole their weapons for no reason, and tried to make them join a fight that they're not a part of. Oceanside are now completely defenseless from walkers or group attacks, how stupid it is taking ALL their weapons. Rick is no different from Negan in that respect.

I really like the character Cyndie though I hope this isn't the last we see of her/Oceanside.

[Headie]

This is like the first episode I've watched in like 4 weeks and I don't feel like I've missed any of the storyline at all, it's incredibly slow which is what is making me lose interest.

[Amy Jade]

I agree Hayden in reguards to Cyndie, I'd love her to be given a larger role.

[Ninastar]

i feel like Cyndie (which is also her name on thats so raven lmao) is gonna end up a love interest for tara

also i ****ing laughed so hard when the kid was like 'so you're taking all our guns?' and tara was like yes, **** you lmao

i thought the episode last night was really good!!! im looking forward to next week

[Natalie.]

This season hasn't been the best, hopefully getting ready fo s8 to be great
I also really like Cyndie and it probably is setting up for her and Tara

Can't wait for the last ep, looks good from the preview

[user104658]

Originally Posted by Hayden

Ugh I actually hate Rick and co's mentality that they're the good guys when they just raided a completely innocent, off-the-radar group and stole their weapons for no reason, and tried to make them join a fight that they're not a part of. Oceanside are now completely defenseless from walkers or group attacks, how stupid it is taking ALL their weapons. Rick is no different from Negan in that respect.

It was all a bit... aggressive from the outset and a touch unrealistic. It would have been more in character for them to try harder to convince them first...

On the other hand I don't think them taking the guns is all that problematic. It's been shown time after time that people don't need guns to deal with walkers; in fact I always find it ridiculous at this point when they waste ammo on them. Although ammo seems to be in curiously abundant supply . As for human attacks, the only group they're really at risk from is The Saviours, who they have already said they don't want to fight... ... and if they did show up and they started shooting, their village would most likely be wiped out, so it's probably a GOOD thing they don't have guns in that respect.

[Nicky91]

i found it a good episode, i do not trust Dwight at all, now moving to Rick's camp


wow Negan slaying again , and poor Sasha i think a Sasha and Negan leadership could be so badass at the saviors

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

i found it a good episode, i do not trust Dwight at all, now moving to Rick's camp


wow Negan slaying again , and poor Sasha i think a Sasha and Negan leadership could be so badass at the saviors

Are you living in Cuckoo land Nicky, Negan beat Sashas boyfriends head in with a baseball bat and you think she's going to team up with him now?

[user104658]

She was already trying to trick Eugene into giving her a weapon by saying she wanted to kill herself... but Eugene just gave her the poison pill. Maybe she'll put it in her mouth and try to kiss him to death .

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

She was already trying to trick Eugene into giving her a weapon by saying she wanted to kill herself... but Eugene just gave her the poison pill. Maybe she'll put it in her mouth and try to kiss him to death .

[Amy Jade]

Sasha </3

Good episode, it felt a little slow to begin with and frankly as much as the Abe/Sasha scenes were cute they should have just had the one scene it would have been much more powerful and poignant but the last 25 or so minutes were fantastic. Shiva getting some kills was amazing and I am glad all the main cast are back together again, I think the dhow is at it's strongest when everyone is together.

I hope Negan dies soon, he's not even scary or threatening at all just annoying and quite tiring to watch for me, he's not turned out as great as he was in the comics at all. I'd hate them to try and give him a redemption arc.

[Cal.]

The Kingdom and Hilltop showing up <3

Shiva

Maggie's speech at the end

[ChristmasNeeve]

Meh the episode was very anti climactic for me, I agree with Amy, they wasted way too much time on them Abraham/Sasha dream scenes and Negan didn't even die ffs. Also, one thing that bugged me, how did Shiva know which people to attack and which not to? He doesn't know Carl, he could have just as easily bitten his face off

But yeah Maggie as a leader She's way better at it than Rick imo

[Headie]

Am I the only one who finds it annoying as hell when someone is like one centimetre away from using their weapon on someone and are suddenly ~halted~ by an interruption

There's too many "perfect timing" moments lmao