[Ant.]

Originally Posted by Binbin

It's probably no coincidence that Isabelle, as the only English HM, wins over a Welshy, a Nigerian and whatever Raph is. It isn't surprising at all.

Bah, if you're going to vote for best HM then it was Deborah or Tom. I just have to say that Tom's edits did not do him any justice at all. If Andrew and Raph's award to Tom for being the most fun are to be believed, and also Emma's out-of-house remarks about Tom being energetic and fun then WE HAVE BEEN FOOLED once again!

I am delighted Raph didn't win. The bias was nauseating. Plus, as an American, 2nd place is last place, so he'll just have to tap into his Japanese parts for love peace and harmony.

right, so people supporting their friend and a fellow forum member is nauseating, but comments about his race aren't? get outta here

[Binbin]

Originally Posted by Lilbro

right, so people supporting their friend and a fellow forum member is nauseating, but comments about his race aren't? get outta here

Well, it's a bit complicated, but it's not about race, it's about cultural identity, and how, in Raph's case, multiple identities might shape his persona.

He has an advantage because they might fuse together, like a an alloy, into a kind of super-identity. So, Raph can be American, and strategise to win, and also be Japanese and feel the pleasure of Isabelle's victory. Japanese culture is very interesting. And yes, the Japanese are a distinct race, so for them, it is ALL about race - but not for me, and I hope not for you.

[Ant.]

Originally Posted by Binbin

Well, it's a bit complicated, but it's not about race, it's about cultural identity, and how, in Raph's case, multiple identities might shape his persona.

He has an advantage because they might fuse together, like a an alloy, into a kind of super-identity. So, Raph can be American, and strategise to win, and also be Japanese and feel the pleasure of Isabelle's victory. Japanese culture is very interesting. And yes, the Japanese are a distinct race, so for them, it is ALL about race - but not for me, and I hope not for you.

you're nasty BYE

[ClaireS92]

Originally Posted by Lilbro

right, so people supporting their friend and a fellow forum member is nauseating, but comments about his race aren't? get outta here

People voted for Izzy because she was the most genuine one left and the nicest That s all .