[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Ross.

I will not stand for this Dannii shade

Dannii's better than Cheryl but in much the same vein I don't remember any standout moments of her time as a judge? She was a good mentor but that's not important to me

I'd rank the female judges like this:

Sharon
Nicole
Mel
Alexandra (I'm not joking, okaydotcomthankyou is more iconic than the rest of this list)
Kelly
Tulisa
Dannii
Cheryl
Rita

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Dannii's better than Cheryl but in much the same vein I don't remember any standout moments of her time as a judge? She was a good mentor but that's not important to me

I'd rank the female judges like this:

Sharon
Nicole
Mel
Alexandra (I'm not joking, okaydotcomthankyou is more iconic than the rest of this list)
Kelly
Tulisa
Dannii
Cheryl
Rita

Put Rita above Cheryl and I completely agree

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Ross.

We need a Nicole-Sharon-Cheryl-Dannii panel to save the ratings

How DARE you suggest they remove this wonderful man again



A reminder that last time they did that we ended up with this

Spoiler:

Originally Posted by Withano

Put Rita above Cheryl and I completely agree

I love Rita more than almost all of them, but I remember literally nothing of her time as a judge (I try to block that series out of my head tbh). At least Cheryl's (still) ongoing feud with Louis was low-key amusing

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Jack_

How DARE you suggest they remove this wonderful man again



A reminder that last time they did that we ended up with this

Spoiler:

Ugh, you have wonderful x factor judging panel opinions.

I dont remember rita either lol, thats why shes better than cheryl, I dont remember being constantly frustrated when she appeared onscreen, so she nips it.