[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Women are born with a womb and a reproduction system India was not and cannot buy one either so will NEVER be a woman ,even after the menopause or hysterectomy you are still a woman, what a stupid,ill informed comment to make and an nasty thing to say ,as women have had hysterectomies through cancer etc

When did I make a statement that women who can't give birth or who don't have the organs to do so due to various circumstances don't count as women?

You made this flawed statement

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Neither of them will ever be a woman, they have no womb ,they cannot have a child so not a woman .... Simple !!

These are your words, I just asked for clarification, I'm not sure how that warrants such a vitriolic reaction from you? You stated that women who don't have the organs or cannot have children aren't women so I brought up those two examples in order to highlight the massive flaw in that statement, that you only count women as women on whether or not they can have children or not.

I think that's a grim way of thinking and it's detrimental to think of women as nothing more than baby factories but that's what you reduced them to in your definition of what makes a woman a woman in that post.