[Z]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Isn't that what it is all the time?

'I came from a little town in Sheffield'

'hehe To think I was milking a cow in my nan's farm last month and now I'm a star!'

'You know, I wouldn't of thought that coming from my little council flat that 4 months later I'd end up with a chance to win The X Factor, it's just amazing!'

'I grew up in a street near a mountain, so I think I should win'


Same bollocks constantly.

Laughing SO much at the bit in bold!

[MusicXian]

Being fair to the contestants. It's not them who force this stuff on to the public, the show is edited into this.

[Ammi]

I love her voice and she has an adorable face........

[ArcticLion]

Dont like her at all, well i did at her audition but even then when everyone was spreading the love about her i said she was overrated and average, but now she just does my head in with the whole 'im just a normal girl, ive never had anything apart from a fat chicken who had babies' act, gahhh i hate her. Amelia FTW

[nanaimo]

Love

[Gary2010]

Originally Posted by SaphLiike

Cant stand her! Diana Vickers take 2! and I hated Diana hate Janet more.. shes got ugly teeth and that is just not on!

You got it in one

[robb]

Originally Posted by Gary2010

You got it in one

I didn't like Vickers from the start, but I warmed to JANET AT THE AUDITIONS. My concern is that Kelly will turn her INTO another Vickers. I honestly believe Janet has far far more to offer......but whether she can win a messed up show like XF is more doubtful. Lets face it, Adele would have probably been booted out at the judges house stage .....

[Gillian-73]

Love her! not just her voice either she seems a lovely sweet young girl, i'm looking forward to seeing more of her

[Kerry]

Thought she was the best tonight

[Visage]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

Thought she was the best tonight

Yes. I loved this song until it was over played and she's turned it around and now I love it all over again.

[GabbygalEvs]

i dont get her its not that i hate her shes sweet but i dont get the overrated praise she gets

she cant hold notes for long at all she says everything its just not singing

[reece(:]

can't stand her

amelia>

[robb]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

Thought she was the best tonight

She was up there.....let's hear her get through this week before we judge her too soon. She is more likeable than most of the others mind

[stewart64]

I thinks she looks great, probably the most attractive girl this year. Comes across as a bit prococious, but she could still win me over. Not really as likeable as the humble Sophie.

[MusicXian]

I think in the space of a week they made her seem like an adorable, shy young chick into a fiery, arrogant diva and they may pay for that in the future.

That said she was great again.

[stewart64]

Originally Posted by MusicXian

I think in the space of a week they made her seem like an adorable, shy young chick into a fiery, arrogant diva and they may pay for that in the future.

That said she was great again.

Well only having seen this week, I just got the fiery diva bit. And it would be unfair to judge her on one week. I suppose it all comes down to editing.

By contrast Sophie came across really well, but time will tell.

[Niamh.]

Living near a field is atleast an original sob story

But yeah, I love her voice, she's my favourite atm

[Lee.]

She's growing on me... she kind of reminds me of Dolores from the Cranberries (her voice, not how she looks)

I'd like to hear her singing some stirring Celtic folk song... she has the voice for it.

[joeysteele]

I really liked the way she did 'Sweet child of mine'. it worked really well.

[MusicXian]

Yeah the cranberries lead singer is what I said after her first audition while most said Diana vickers.

[MusicXian]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Well only having seen this week, I just got the fiery diva bit. And it would be unfair to judge her on one week. I suppose it all comes down to editing.

By contrast Sophie came across really well, but time will tell.

Watch her other performances she is adorable. Her actual performance this week was actually her best IMO just that they or herself changed the way she is.

[fruit_cake]

strongly like

[Strictly Jake]

I liked how she defended against herself against the horrible press people. She was a hundred percent right she shouldnt have to change who she is for anything or anyone. She is lovely who she is and tons of people like her so she should stay true to who she is. She really showed a lot more personality this weekend which is good to see, her coming out of her shell. I have a feeling she is going to do something incredible on saturday