[Shaun]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

We're too bored to bake every week.

maybe don't call it a bake-off then

[Nicky91]

but some new things to know: you can also bake a cake or pie or biscuits yourselves and as i'm one of the 2 judges, i can say this for sure, you'll get extra points for baking things yourself, but finding pictures of cakes from google is allowed, only not very helpful in getting high marks

[Amy Jade]

Ill be a contestant

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

well if you're a judge you need to know something about cakes and pies and biscuits and breads

[Drew.]

Been hard at work today making a cake specifically for this game

[caprimint]

Novo has got this in the bag

[Morgan.]

I can be a judge, Nicky

[LukeB]

This sounds like a good idea but my opinion is searching for pictures from google could be boring and it's not really baking. People could bake or even design it with different software or even drawing it.

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by LukeB

This sounds like a good idea but my opinion is searching for pictures from google could be boring and it's not really baking. People could bake or even design it with different software or even drawing it.

I think this could work really well, having people bake or draw. Obviously we couldn't expect people to,back three things for 10 weeks or so the drawing could be an option with finding pictures as a complete last option.

[Amy Jade]

I'd actually bake lol

[Ammi]

...good luck with this, Nicky......I'll look forward to seeing the bakes...(Amy....)...

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

Ill be a contestant

Originally Posted by ProfessorSmooth

I can be a judge, Nicky

thank you Amy and Professor i'll update the list now

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Drew.

Been hard at work today making a cake specifically for this game

okay a nice cake, and i'll add you as a contestant

[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by LukeB

This sounds like a good idea but my opinion is searching for pictures from google could be boring and it's not really baking. People could bake or even design it with different software or even drawing it.

Designing them is another great idea I'd probably give it a go if that happens, could be a lot of fun!

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

Designing them is another great idea I'd probably give it a go if that happens, could be a lot of fun!

yeah that is also a great idea

[Nicky91]

this is more Jamie's idea, i kinda did this myself



Orange-Lemon drizzle cake

[ArgyESC]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

Designing them is another great idea I'd probably give it a go if that happens, could be a lot of fun!

I don't like this idea.

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

I don't like this idea.

call it multiple choices of doing these cakes, or pictures from google, or drawing them or baking them yourselves and sending a picture of your bake on here

[Ammi]

.....hmmmm, maybe it needs some thought of how it's going to work, Nicky and have a definite score plan laid out..?.../so for instance, contestants can only get a potential maximum score for a googled pic but a higher maximum potential one for a 'designed bake' and a higher one again for an actual bake and posting of it..?...multiple choices but with only the potential of an appropriate maximum points attached..?...

[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

this is more Jamie's idea, i kinda did this myself



Orange-Lemon drizzle cake

(It was Luke's idea really, I was just supporting it ... not me stealing credit )

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

I don't like this idea.

It could be an alternative for people who'd rather not bake or use pre-existing images... so if you'd rather not design them you wouldn't have to. It would just mean there's different ways of taking part to suit different peoples preferences.

It's up to you of course though Nicky, they're just suggestions

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

(It was Luke's idea really, I was just supporting it ... not me stealing credit )



It could be an alternative for people who'd rather not bake or use pre-existing images... so if you'd rather not design them you wouldn't have to. It would just mean there's different ways of taking part to suit different peoples preferences.

It's up to you of course though Nicky, they're just suggestions

...yeah, I think it's a good thing to have a little 'think tank' here for this game/competition, Jamie.....

[Ammi]

..well done LukeB....

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

(It was Luke's idea really, I was just supporting it ... not me stealing credit )



It could be an alternative for people who'd rather not bake or use pre-existing images... so if you'd rather not design them you wouldn't have to. It would just mean there's different ways of taking part to suit different peoples preferences.

It's up to you of course though Nicky, they're just suggestions

thank you Jamie, and it's good to have multiple suggestions in this game



but also i've sent Josy a pm, about a cupcake award perhaps with this game

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Ammi

.....hmmmm, maybe it needs some thought of how it's going to work, Nicky and have a definite score plan laid out..?.../so for instance, contestants can only get a potential maximum score for a googled pic but a higher maximum potential one for a 'designed bake' and a higher one again for an actual bake and posting of it..?...multiple choices but with only the potential of an appropriate maximum points attached..?...

Just came up with this, it could work quite well. The person with the most points that week gets Star Baker, the person with least gets eliminated. It removes any bias people might have to some extent too.

Points System
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 5
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 8
Max Points for Baked - 10
Technical Challenge
Cannot win with Googled Image
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 8
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 15
Max Points for Baked - 20

[LeatherTrumpet]

can you have your cake and eat it?