[Stacey.]

Cher's a good singer though..

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by stacey.x

cher's a good singer though..

on what planet!?

[M X]

tbh, if it was something to do with her versa then you can't blame cheryl. however, you can't blame cheryl for anything. it's her choice, her decision & lets face it, cher and katie's past performances have been brilliant.

[Joelle.]

cher and katie's past performances have been brilliant

Im sorry but on what planet?!

Katie has broken down on two of her three performances without being able to sing the song properly. Doesn't really say much for the live shows does it?
And Cher had an okay audition but from then on in she has been utter ****e and like Katie broke down at judges houses.

[Tom4784]

You're naive if you think this is just to cover Cheryl's ass as that would mean you think you judges (apart from Simon) have any say of who goes through. Cheryl, Dannii and Louis get told who to put through while Simon puts on the theatrics for acts he hates to create drama. It's all fake, nothing that isn't live from the X Factor (and even then it shouldn't be taken as gospel) should ever be taken as the truth.

The audition stages rely on a lot of setups.

[Jack_]

As I said, the lives will be a real test for her. If she can hold it together then she evidently deserves her place, but if she messes up [her words] then I'll take back what I said and accept that maybe she didn't deserve her place. One thing is for sure though, she and Cher are a damn sight more interesting than some of the other girls that were in her category.

[Twilight]

Gamu was hardly amazing and she was dull. so just get over it, she wasn't picked, big deal.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Twilight

Gamu was hardly amazing and she was dull. so just get over it, she wasn't picked, big deal.

I think she had an amazing voice. I think people wouldn't be as annoyed if Katie and Cher hadn't messed their auditions up so badly

[Twilight]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I think she had an amazing voice. I think people wouldn't be as annoyed if Katie and Cher hadn't messed their auditions up so badly

I agree that it pissed me off when they put Katie in, but Cher was sick, so i think she should have another chance.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Twilight

I agree that it pissed me off when they put Katie in, but Cher was sick, so i think she should have another chance.

well, she was offered a chance to come back later which she refused...........

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

yes well I don't think Mary should be in the top 12 either!

Point taken

Though the Over 28's were pretty awful anyway, I think Louis picked the right three - they stood out the most, apart from John - he's pretty dull and I don't remember him at all apart from Judge's Houses.

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

I suppose it depends what you enjoy watching. Some people like the auditions more than the serious stuff because they like watching people make fools of themselves etc. and the light hearted acts. Some people prefer the live shows because they like watching people develop as singers and show off the real talent. Some people enjoy both. I personally prefer the serious stuff.

I also prefer the Live Shows. Judge's Houses onward is my favourite part of the show, the Auditions bore me after a while. But the fact is I still like some entertainment, just entertainment that has talent, so i.e Cher and Katie. If it's a choice between a talented bore [Keri etc] or a talented entertainer [Cher, Katie], I'll chose the latter. And they are the types that deserve a place in the Live Shows...because they're the ones people will be talking about and tuning in for.

Originally Posted by Twilight

Gamu was hardly amazing and she was dull. so just get over it, she wasn't picked, big deal.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Point taken

Though the Over 28's were pretty awful anyway, I think Louis picked the right three - they stood out the most, apart from John - he's pretty dull and I don't remember him at all apart from Judge's Houses.



I also prefer the Live Shows. Judge's Houses onward is my favourite part of the show, the Auditions bore me after a while. But the fact is I still like some entertainment, just entertainment that has talent, so i.e Cher and Katie. If it's a choice between a talented bore [Keri etc] or a talented entertainer [Cher, Katie], I'll chose the latter. And they are the types that deserve a place in the Live Shows...because they're the ones people will be talking about and tuning in for.

I didn't remember John either but I loved him at judges house. I would have had him, Storm and Elesha in the overs but lets be honest none of them are contenders anyway

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I didn't remember John either but I loved him at judges house. I would have had him, Storm and Elesha in the overs but lets be honest none of them are contenders anyway

I remember Wagner but for all the wrong reasons

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

I remember Wagner but for all the wrong reasons

yeah i cant get him out of my head because of that fake account.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

I remember Wagner but for all the wrong reasons

lmao, yes well I think everyone remembers Wagner!

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

yeah they shouldnt when cheryl put 2 singers through that sang or in chers case rapped ****, and they forgot there words.

Yeah yeah so youve said..a million times.

Originally Posted by Twilight

Gamu was hardly amazing and she was dull. so just get over it, she wasn't picked, big deal.

Twilight has spoken!

Stand back and behold.

[Zippy]

LMAO at all you on this thread yapping like Cheryl is up in court or summat!

She made a decision....one which MANY of us agree with. Just GET OVER IT you crybabies. Not everybody rates Gamu either so quit talking like she has spectacular talent. She doesnt!

Just a pathetic excuse to spit hate at Cheryl. She doesnt have to justify her choice to a bunch of haters on internet forums. Most people dont care either way truthfully. As always, its just a loud few making lots of noise.

Gamu isnt even as good as the other girls who lost out.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Zippy

LMAO at all you on this thread yapping like Cheryl is up in court or summat!

She made a decision....one which MANY of us agree with. Just GET OVER IT you crybabies. Not everybody rates Gamu either so quit talking like she has spectacular talent. She doesnt!

Just a pathetic excuse to spit hate at Cheryl. She doesnt have to justify her choice to a bunch of haters on internet forums. Most people dont care either way truthfully. As always, its just a loud few making lots of noise.

Gamu isnt even as good as the other girls who lost out.

Well it is the X-Factor forum Zippy.....

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

LMAO at all you on this thread yapping like Cheryl is up in court or summat!

She made a decision....one which MANY of us agree with. Just GET OVER IT you crybabies. Not everybody rates Gamu either so quit talking like she has spectacular talent. She doesnt!

Just a pathetic excuse to spit hate at Cheryl. She doesnt have to justify her choice to a bunch of haters on internet forums. Most people dont care either way truthfully. As always, its just a loud few making lots of noise.

Gamu isnt even as good as the other girls who lost out.

actually the people sticking up for cheryl are a few people on the internet forums that fancy her.

and most people are annoyed at cheryl otherwise her hate wouldnt have been the 2nd most trending on twitter and there wouldnt be people on facebook still being really annoyed that there still joining the gamu should have gone through campaign.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

actually the people sticking up for cheryl are a few people on the internet forums that fancy her.

and most people are annoyed at cheryl otherwise her hate wouldnt have been the 2nd most trending on twitter and there wouldnt be people on facebook still being really annoyed that there still joining the gamu should have gone through campaign.

Personally Im neither interested or impressed by whats trending on twitter sh!tter.

Its just meaningless piffpaff. Internet geekoids will join any stupid campaign if its publicised enough. Do you seriously think all those on the Gamu petition really give a toss about her? Like hell. Just bandwagon jumping and trying to get a dig at Cheryl and the Xfactor producers.

And its not about sticking up for Cheryl. She doesnt need defending in the slightest as far as Im concerned. It was her decision not yours and she has EVERY RIGHT to follow her own judgement and instincts. She's the one that has to work with these artists at the end of the day.

It actually irritates me to see some Cheryl fans pleading her case because they really dont need to justify jacksh!t.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Personally Im neither interested or impressed by whats trending on twitter sh!tter.

Its just meaningless piffpaff. Internet geekoids will join any stupid campaign if its publicised enough. Do you seriously think all those on the Gamu petition really give a toss about her? Like hell. Just bandwagon jumping and trying to get a dig at Cheryl and the Xfactor producers.

And its not about sticking up for Cheryl. She doesnt need defending in the slightest as far as Im concerned. It was her decision not yours and she has EVERY RIGHT to follow her own judgement and instincts. She's the one that has to work with these artists at the end of the day.

It actually irritates me to see some Cheryl fans pleading her case because they really dont need to justify jacksh!t.

yeah they shouldnt when cheryl put 2 singers through that sang or in chers case rapped ****, and they forgot there words.

[Marsh.]

The argument that Gamu is a bit reserved, quiet and more boring than the others is crap. Cher "crackhead" Lloyd is hardly life and soul and Katie is a spoilt arrogant cow. Hardly qualities I enjoy from a performer.
And didn't Leona Lewis become the most successful X Factor winner and I still haven't seen a shred of a personality.

[joeysteele]

How on earth for any reason can you set up a competition to decide finalists for live shows to the public,have auditions first, then boot camp to sort out the people who get the final chance to really shine by showing their determination and talent by having them go to the judges house to perform singly.
In other words the last chance to shine in order to prove that the auditions was not an end to the talent but the start of the talent.but...

Then, to have 2 people with places in that final at stake, not performing, not completing a song and refusing the chance to return and try again.

Come on, if you were going for a job,and you were asked questions, you answer only a few or in Chers case even none, would you get the job, of course not.
Cheryl made a decision on nothing she saw at the house,there was no drive, energy ,enthusiasm, singing, remembering the words and no performance.

She made the wrong choices and wrong decisions,that's why the public are furious because they could see what Cheryl couldn't and that is that Cher and Katie are useless no hopers.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

How on earth for any reason can you set up a competition to decide finalists for live shows to the public,have auditions first, then boot camp to sort out the people who get the final chance to really shine by showing their determination and talent by having them go to the judges house to perform singly.
In other words the last chance to shine in order to prove that the auditions was a start not an end to the talent.

Then, to have 2 people with places in that final at stake, not performing, not completing a song and refusing the chance to return and try again.
Come on, if you were going for a job,and you were asked questions, you answer only a few or in Chers case even none, would you get the job, of course not.
Cheryl made a decision on nothing she saw at the house,there was no drive, energy ,enthusiasm, singing, remembering the words and no performance.

She made the wronng choices and wrong decisions,that's why the public are furious because they could see what Cheryl couldn't and that is that Cher and Katie are useless no hopers.

agreed.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

She made the wronng choices and wrong decisions,that's why the public are furious

Oh plz. The public? what, all of them? pmsl

There is no wrong decision. Its about different tastes and opinions. Talent and potential are not an exact science and no artist on the planet is universally liked or enjoyed.

Gamu is out. FFS get over it. So much fuss over such an average and funny looking little thing.