[MTVN]

Lots of reasons really, humans contribute to society by working, paying tax, through their general involvement in communities, having much more opportunity to influence events and circumstances etc. plus they have much longer lifespans, have larger social circles, connections and families, and they have increased intelligence, emotions, awareness etc. etc.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

erm my dog/cat is better than them

[Apple202]

All of that is just based from a human perspective - does anything else care about human communities or paying taxes? Why should because they are involved in human social circles should effect whether they should be saved or not?

Surely in terms of the environment, the life of the pet and/or other animals is worth more than a human which is just destroying and depleting all the resources in the world..

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Lots of reasons really, humans contribute to society by working, paying tax, through their general involvement in communities, having much more opportunity to influence events and circumstances etc. plus they have much longer lifespans, have larger social circles, connections and families, and they have increased intelligence, emotions, awareness etc. etc.

dog's contriute to society, some work and they are great companions.
They have social circles and emotions.
My dog is 100% worth more than some people I know tbh

And... dogs can smell cancer ... can humans smell cancer?...

http://www.nhs.uk/news/2011/08August...ng-cancer.aspx

[MTVN]

Humans are capable of much more sophisticated and abstract thought though, it's why we've been able to progress so much, discover so much, learn so much, create so much etc. humans as a species are able to do so much more than animals are

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

dog's contriute to society, some work and they are great companions.
They have social circles and emotions.
My dog is 100% worth more than some people I know tbh

And... dogs can smell cancer ... can humans smell cancer?...

http://www.nhs.uk/news/2011/08August...ng-cancer.aspx

Can a dog carry out chemotherapy?

[GypsyGoth]

I wouldn't save either of them, they should both be able to look after themselves.

[Josy]

I'm just wondering to all those have said they would save a dog/cat before a human, would you be able to handle the guilt of another human being dying if you solely could have prevented it, would you feel any guilt at all?

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Humans are capable of much more sophisticated and abstract thought though, it's why we've been able to progress so much, discover so much, learn so much, create so much etc. humans as a species are able to do so much more than animals are

We are animals, and it's hard to know what other species are thinking or feeling I guess.
Dogs are highly intelligent creatures though, and I can well understand why some would prefer their company to other humans lol

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Josy

I'm just wondering to all those have said they would save a dog/cat before a human, would you be able to handle the guilt of another human being dying if you solely could have prevented it, would you feel any guilt at all?

I'd feel guilty at first, then I'd get over it

[MTVN]

I know we're technically animals, I'm just making the distinction for convenience

[Josy]

Originally Posted by Apple202

I'd feel guilty at first, then I'd get over it

Hmm would you though? I think for most people it wouldnt be as easy as just getting over it tbh.

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by MTVN

I know we're technically animals, I'm just making the distinction for convenience

Well, thanks for that

[MTVN]

My pleasure kizzy

[Jessica.]

I love my cat so much, I would definitely save her.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Josy

Hmm would you though? I think for most people it wouldnt be as easy as just getting over it tbh.

I don't know. I know that I would feel guilty and probably awful for at least a few months, and maybe I wouldn't get over it... but maybe i would lol i have no idea

But I'd still save my dog

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Josy

I'm just wondering to all those have said they would save a dog/cat before a human, would you be able to handle the guilt of another human being dying if you solely could have prevented it, would you feel any guilt at all?

Very good point. speaking for myself, I would feel really guilty at not being able to save all in trouble.
I would though too feel awfully guilty and equally sad at not being able to save my pet either.
It's a likely no win situation really I guess.

Very thought provoking point though Josy.

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Josy

I'm just wondering to all those have said they would save a dog/cat before a human, would you be able to handle the guilt of another human being dying if you solely could have prevented it, would you feel any guilt at all?

I may feel remorse, regret, pity, guilt... but I made my decision.

[Niamh.]

No of course not, I love my dogs but a person would always come first

[Niamh.]

wow can't believe the Poll results, that's pretty shocking tbh

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

Are you saying my dogs life is worth less than a humans?....

Yes.

[SharkAttack]

This is one of those 'impossible things to know unless it actually happened' kind of polls. I'd say I would love to save an adult, or child who is drowning over my beloved dog or cat(I've had both,) because it makes sense. But I'd most likely go freestyling after my dog the second he went in, as a natural instinct. He's my kid, in this case. However, a screaming 3 year-old is probably going to sway me from the pet, or a screaming man/woman.

No offense Apple, but this is a **** question, because it's not something you can answer honestly or declare at any moment, without it happening in real time. Hypotheticals are fun but usually nonsense.

[Marc]

I'd save my dog and by the looks of it others would, over saving my life so I don't feel too bad.

[AnnieK]

I'd have to save the person as karma is a bitch and I would hate to save my pet only to find myself drowning the week later and someone saving their dog over me....

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by anniek76

I'd have to save the person as karma is a bitch and I would hate to save my pet only to find myself drowning the week later and someone saving their dog over me....

haha exactly.

I really can't believe people are saying they'd save their pet over another human, I'd like to think that if they were actually in the situation they'd change there mind.