[Stephanie]

he was still really good, just not as amazing as usual
he was still better than a few people

[Tom]

because he was

[LemonJam]

I don't remember his vocals, just dancing.

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by Tom

because he was

This.

[MrGaryy]

I don't get it either Stef. I thought he was below par but still very good, considering he had a broken knuckle. The reason people think Lloyd was better than him was because Lloyd was given a song with zero vocal range all he had to do was trapse around the stage clicking his fingers mumbling the lyrics.

[MarkWaldorf]

because he's become too predictable and even his huge fanbase can't defend that performance. like i said a few weeks ago, those who peak too early may not go all the way because it takes one performance to win this thing (alex - listen etc).

[Crimson Dynamo]

he danced well but as Danny said he was drowned out vocally. just a bad song choice.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by MrGaryy

I don't get it either Stef. I thought he was below par but still very good, considering he had a broken knuckle. The reason people think Lloyd was better than him was because Lloyd was given a song with zero vocal range all he had to do was trapse around the stage clicking his fingers mumbling the lyrics.

what does a broken finger have to do with his singing?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I thought it was oaky.

[MrGaryy]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

because he's become too predictable and even his huge fanbase can't defend that performance. like i said a few weeks ago, those who peak too early may not go all the way because it takes one performance to win this thing (alex - listen etc).

I can completely defend that performance. His vocals were up to standard, he put on a show and with a broken knuckle which is more than can be said for some others. It wasn't his best but it was still a good performance.

[Jords]

First off, he was the worst out the lot of them last night, normally he is is better than Jedward and Llyod, but they upped their game.
Secondly his song choices are predictable and slightly tedious now, and hes only getting through because of all the dancing (which has become annoying) and maybe his looks, but girls tend to prefer Llyod I think?

Tbh Im starting to like Jedward slightly more, so bottom 2 should be Olly & Llyod, (Lloyd may not be better vocally, but is more versitile) with probably Olly going, but it wont be.

[Chels]

I was disappointed tbh :/

[Tom]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

because he's become too predictable and even his huge fanbase can't defend that performance. like i said a few weeks ago, those who peak too early may not go all the way because it takes one performance to win this thing (alex - listen etc).

The performance usually comes about now- if Stacey can follow up her performance next week then shes won it

[MrGaryy]

Originally Posted by Tom

what does a broken finger have to do with his singing?

nothing. My point was that he still managed to put on a show and entertain with a broken knuckle while maintaining a good vocal which was unfortunately drowned out by the the music this week.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Tom

what does a broken finger have to do with his singing?

Double, maybe triple this.

If he was in pain, he should not done a dance routine, but hey, without dancing he would probably lose a lot of fans.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by MrGaryy

nothing. My point was that he still managed to put on a show and entertain with a broken knuckle while maintaining a good vocal which was unfortunately drowned out by the the music this week.

He was hardly crippled though, the knuckle is irrelevant imo

If you want real bravery you should've watched Laila on last nights SCD.

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by Jords

If he was in pain, he should not done a dance routine, but hey, without dancing he would probably lose a lot of fans.

Truth.

[Lewis.]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

because he's become too predictable and even his huge fanbase can't defend that performance. like i said a few weeks ago, those who peak too early may not go all the way because it takes one performance to win this thing (alex - listen etc).

This.

[Patrick]

He should of been ace at that song, and he wasnt.

[MrGaryy]

Originally Posted by Jords

First off, he was the worst out the lot of them last night, normally he is is better than Jedward and Llyod, but they upped their game.
Secondly his song choices are predictable and slightly tedious now, and hes only getting through because of all the dancing (which has become annoying) and maybe his looks, but girls tend to prefer Llyod I think?

Tbh Im starting to like Jedward slightly more, so bottom 2 should be Olly & Llyod, (Lloyd may not be better vocally, but is more versitile) with probably Olly going, but it wont be.

]

Lloyd gets the teenage girl while Olly gets the older ladies.

This versatile thing is totally unfair in my opinion. It was Simon's choice to take him down this retro route and him who has provided the songs every week. Olly's never gotten the chance to show versatility due to Simon's song choices. and to say Lloyd is more versatile when he has had the opportunity to try out lots of different styles and genres and failed at all of the is ludicrous.

As a Olly fan, I really want Simon to drop this 50s **** he keeps giving him and hopefully give him a ballad next week.

[MrGaryy]

Originally Posted by Tom

He was hardly crippled though, the knuckle is irrelevant imo

If you want real bravery you should've watched Laila on last nights SCD.

I'm not making out he's some great martyr I'm just saying it was another obstacle in his way.

and I don't. :P

[Stephanie]

tbh last night lloyd looked like a wannabe olly

[Jords]

Originally Posted by MrGaryy

]

Lloyd gets the teenage girl while Olly gets the older ladies.

This versatile thing is totally unfair in my opinion. It was Simon's choice to take him down this retro route and him who has provided the songs every week. Olly's never gotten the chance to show versatility due to Simon's song choices. and to say Lloyd is more versatile when he has had the opportunity to try out lots of different styles and genres and failed at all of the is ludicrous.

As a Olly fan, I really want Simon to drop this 50s **** he keeps giving him and hopefully give him a ballad next week.

Okey doke

I honestly dont think Olly is very versitile, hes a bit like Leon, only really good at that sort of song, poor at anything else. Llyod has tried out a much larger range, and although might not have been ace at them (some actually quite poor), at least he gave them a shot, instead of sticking him in his comfort zone, which deserves more respect than prancing around a stage every week (a bit like Jedward, but they go into acting a bit too, which is different).

If Danyl was allowed to dance, Olly would probably look bad compared to him anyway. I think Simon knows Olly is only getting through by dancing, so is not allowing Danyl to? Just a theory

[Chels]

Originally Posted by Stephanie

tbh last night lloyd looked like a wannabe olly

erm, how?
they're both completley different, i didn't see lloyd doing no dancing.
and imo lloyd was better than olly last night.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Stephanie

tbh last night lloyd looked like a wannabe olly

They both have a monotone voice and make every song sound the same, yep I can definitely see the comparison!!