[Joe.]

Cheryl

Sorry but, she called beautiful Katie a drama queen yet Cher causes a drama and it's all hugs and kisses. Cher even refused another go 'I'm done, I'm done' and yet I bet she'll still get through. Bumlicker.

[Z]

Yep. Sad state of affairs.

[Stacey.]

That's why she'll make it through She knows what she can do.

[Lee.]

They're both chavtastic that's why!

[Jordan.]

Katie is far more dramatic than Cher, well tries to be.

Cheryl has seen something in Cher from the start and its her choice if she wants to put her through.

[GiRTh]

LOL Stace. Loyal to the end.

Agree with the OP Cheryl's clueless.

[Joe.]

I just don't like the way Cheryl treats some different to others. She adores Cher.

If it had been Simon in charge it would have been-

Gamu, Katie & Treyc (possibly Rebecca)

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

LOL Stace. Loyal to the end.

Yep. She'll go a long way.

[Zippy]

Cheryl has to go with who she believes in. If she see's something special in Cher then she should pick her. Most artists split opinion anyways so its better to have an interesting artist who gets people talking rather than a dull artist with a decent voice. Truly amazing voices are very rare.

[MeMyselfAndI]

nah i think Simon would of picked
Cher,Gamu and Treyc or Rebecca

[Legend killer]

I actually think Cher may be Chery'sl secret daughter

Now that would be some headline for 2moz's news of the world

[Stacey.]

Simon would've chosen Gamu, Rebecca and TreyC I think.

Just as well Cheryl has the girls.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Simon would've chosen Gamu, Rebecca and TreyC I think.

Just as well Cheryl has the girls.

I dont think Simon would have chosen TreyC he didn't before

[Jords]

Well said OP.

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I dont think Simon would have chosen TreyC he didn't before

Yeah, although I think he might've changed his mind about her this time round.

[joeysteele]

Simon is not sympathetic at all to acts failing to perform and complete a song, he would have likely said, too young, maybe come back next year.
Cheryl will find when she puts here through that this will happen on the live shows, for the reason Cher will not be picking what she sings, she will have to sing songs she won't feel comfortable with and that's the big problem.
This song tonight was far from suited to her too.

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Simon would've chosen Gamu, Rebecca and TreyC I think.

Just as well Cheryl has the girls.

Actually if Simon did make those choices he would be right in doing so. If Cher doesn't go through it is definetely the right choice. You have to earn your place in the live show by performing consistently well and Cher has just got worse. I don't expect a hardcore Cher fan to understand this though as in your eyes she can clearly do no wrong.

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

Actually if Simon did make those choices he would be right in doing so. If Cher doesn't go through it is definetely the right choice. You have to earn your place in the live show by performing consistently well and Cher has just got worse. I don't expect a hardcore Cher fan to understand this though as in your eyes she can clearly do no wrong.

But it wasn't actually her fault that she couldn't perform properly, because of her throat. She couldn't control that and she didn't know it was gonna happen. She did her best and at the end, no sound would even come out. At least she tried.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Cheryl has to go with who she believes in. If she see's something special in Cher then she should pick her. Most artists split opinion anyways so its better to have an interesting artist who gets people talking rather than a dull artist with a decent voice. Truly amazing voices are very rare.

I agree, at least Cher is getting people talking whether it's good or bad and not being wallpaper in the background.