[Jack_]

Okay, this might be a bit confusing. It's a multi-poll, just chose one option for both Dermot and Cheryl

[Lewis.]

Both will do both I think...

[Adamw92]

I think Cheryl will do both, Dermot just the UK.

[joeysteele]

I hope Ms Cole does only the USA X factor and does so well she stays over there.

I can't see Dermot doing both shows, but if he did I wouldn't object to that as long as if he does the UK Xfactor as well as the USA one that he doesn't bring Ms Cole back with him from the States.

[cub]

I read that Simon has made a plan to do both. So I can't see why Dermot and Cheryl can't do both either.

I think the Americans who have watched the X Factor on YouTube will want to see Dermot and Cheryl on the American version - possibly Dannii and Louis too. However, even though Louis is Irish and Dannii is Australian, I think the American producers will want it less 'Brit based' and insist they have at least two American judges.

I'm very excited to see what's going to happen.

Dermot hosting. Simon, Cheryl, Paula Abdul and a US producer/manager would be my line up.

[Patrick]

The American's don't want Dermot, he isn't that big anyway.

The American's will take our Cheryl and abuse her and act as if she's theirs JUST as Justin proved the other night, and people said I was talking bollocks a few months back when I said this, they are plotting a very dirty plan to take her from us.


Either way, if one of them leave I'm not watching our version or the American's pathetic version WHICH IS STEALING our show if they just basically take everything off us except Danni and Louis.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by cub

I read that Simon has made a plan to do both. So I can't see why Dermot and Cheryl can't do both either.

I think the Americans who have watched the X Factor on YouTube will want to see Dermot and Cheryl on the American version - possibly Dannii and Louis too. However, even though Louis is Irish and Dannii is Australian, I think the American producers will want it less 'Brit based' and insist they have at least two American judges.

I'm very excited to see what's going to happen.

Dermot hosting. Simon, Cheryl, Paula Abdul and a US producer/manager would be my line up.

A OTT American Voice Over that will sound as if he's voice overing a trailer for a new Nightmare on Elm Street film, will open the show:

'THE X FACTOR, IS OURS, AMERICA'S BIGGEST TALENT SHOW IS HERE, AMERICA'S TALENT, OUR IDEA, IT'S ALL OURS!!'

Evil laugh fades into Theme Tune, OUR Theme Tune with OUR Graphics.

Justin Bieber judges along with Simon and Cheryl and some other 'Big American Name'.

American crowds act as if this is so new and that the X Factor has never been done before

Then there will be thousands upon thousands of OTT contestants begging to have a place and acting as if they know Simon Cowell and as if they own him, just like AI.


Before the first episode finishes, our X Factor will be forgotten on Facebook and Youtube everything will be 'Oh do you mean X Factor USA yah?' and it's like 'NO! FFS!'

It's a nightmare.

Anyone that's excited needs to get out and realise what disaster lies ahead.

[Stacey.]

I think they'll both carry on doing TXFUK.

[Tom]

They aren't allowed to do both

[Mystic Mock]

i sadly think that cheryl will do the x factor uk and the x factor usa,and i think dermot will do the x factor usa.

[_Seth]

Hopefully Cheryl will **** off to the US, leaving just Dannii, Simon and Louis for TXF UK. Dermot should stay, too. Otherwise bring Kate back.

[Saph]

Hopefully both will do the USA and not UK.

They annoy the crap out of me!

[joeysteele]

[QUOTE=cub;3952695]I read that Simon has made a plan to do both. So I can't see why Dermot and Cheryl can't do both either.

Contracts, Ms Cole is a performer of sorts and therefore will have contractual commitments, she cannot likely tie herself up with likely over 6 months of the year doing nothing else but X Factor shows,I would guess Simon will want to have a new mentor/Judge for the UK one so as not to draw too many comparisons.

It may even be whoever has the US contract, then the US producers may not want them doing the UK one too,other than Simon obviously because they're his shows.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Patrick

The American's don't want Dermot, he isn't that big anyway.

The American's will take our Cheryl and abuse her and act as if she's theirs JUST as Justin proved the other night, and people said I was talking bollocks a few months back when I said this, they are plotting a very dirty plan to take her from us.


Either way, if one of them leave I'm not watching our version or the American's pathetic version WHICH IS STEALING our show if they just basically take everything off us except Danni and Louis.

Silly beggars,don't have to plot to get her,they can have her,free of charge,i am glad the US are getting XFactor,it's not stealing ,as all us Brits want to do is ruin it every year with daft campaigns,so Simon should take it off here as all people do is moan about it ,and let the Americans enjoy it,I bet they wont be campaigning to get Wagner types to win.LOL,Serves us right if we lose it.

[Callum]

Cheryl will do both and Dermot just the UK version.

cub Paula Adbul is unable to become a judge as she has her own reality TV show in the states which is America's version of "Got to Dance". I think the most likely lineup is Simon, Cheryl, Nicole/Mariah and someone else.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Phlip

Hopefully Cheryl will **** off to the US, leaving just Dannii, Simon and Louis for TXF UK. Dermot should stay, too. Otherwise bring Kate back.

Better still take XFactor away from UK,lets see what they all campaign for then,maybe we can have a re-run of The Morcombe and Wise!! show instead

[Jordan.]

Didn't Cheryl comfirm shes doing XF USA? If she is they should just replace her on ours, plenty of over people to take her place. Oh and i think Dermot will stay on ours.

[cub]

Originally Posted by Patrick

A OTT American Voice Over that will sound as if he's voice overing a trailer for a new Nightmare on Elm Street film, will open the show:

'THE X FACTOR, IS OURS, AMERICA'S BIGGEST TALENT SHOW IS HERE, AMERICA'S TALENT, OUR IDEA, IT'S ALL OURS!!'

Evil laugh fades into Theme Tune, OUR Theme Tune with OUR Graphics.

Justin Bieber judges along with Simon and Cheryl and some other 'Big American Name'.

American crowds act as if this is so new and that the X Factor has never been done before

Then there will be thousands upon thousands of OTT contestants begging to have a place and acting as if they know Simon Cowell and as if they own him, just like AI.


Before the first episode finishes, our X Factor will be forgotten on Facebook and Youtube everything will be 'Oh do you mean X Factor USA yah?' and it's like 'NO! FFS!'

It's a nightmare.

Anyone that's excited needs to get out and realise what disaster lies ahead.

Tell you what: next time I want to be excited about something I'll ask you permission first.

[Tom]

Can't wait to see Justin Beiber unveiled as the over 28s mentor

[Marc]

I'm a tad bit confused. But I voted anyway

[reece(:]

Both will hopefully go to US to leave our screens!