[fruit_cake]

1 Louis
2 Danni
3 Cheryl
4 Simon (Relegated)

[Jords]

1. Dannii
2. Louis
3. Cheryl
4. Simon

[King Gizzard]

Louis
Dannii




Simon

Cheryl

He was a total knob with Jedward last year but made up for it this year

[Mystic Mock]

my order of favourites.
1.dannii
2.louis
3.simon
3.cheryl

[Jamie.....]

Dannii
Louis (Close 2nd)
Simon
Cheryl

[bbfan1991]

Louis
Dannii


Cheryl
Simon

[Legend killer]

Louis but Danni a very close 2nd

Louis>Danni>Simon>Chavryl

[MTVN]

Louis' been hilarious this year

[Locke.]

Cheryl has been the best this year

[Novo]

Simon closely followed by Cheryl

[Stacey.]

Louis > Cheryl > Simon > Dannii

Louis' always great, he brings the fun to the show :') And Cheryl because she's done an amazing job of mentoring Cher.

[Jack_]

Louis has been ****ing gold this year, so him.

Louis > Dannii > Simon > Cheryl

[fruit_cake]

so far only one vote each for Simon and Cheryl

[Novo]

Originally Posted by christmas_cake

so far only one vote each for Simon and Cheryl

Ironically the two most intelligent people on the forum

[joeysteele]

Dannii has been my favourite judge/mentor since she joined the show for her honesty and constructive comments.

Then it would be Louis 2nd, Simon 3rd and Cheryl Cole last,for me anyway.

[Niamh.]

1. Dannii
2. Louis
3. Cheryl
4. Simon

[Z]

Dannii > (surprisingly) Louis > Simon > Cheryl.

Dannii actually gives useful comments and is the only judge who, in my opinion, has done her job as a judge well this year. Louis does give the occasional good comment but generally spouts crap about getting people to vote for ____ and makes me cringe but he does have his moments, Simon's been useless all year and Cheryl never gives anything constructive. I think Cheryl's strengths are in mentoring, Dannii's are in judging, Louis is a bit of a spare part nowadays and Simon needs to go away and learn how to be mean again .

[robb]

Dannii.....pleased for her.
Even though I wanted Rebecca to do well........that was Despite Cheryl, not because of her.