[TomC]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

Oh I assume you never heard of Kel Mitchell then

Nope haha

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by TomC

The Australian Outback:
Tina
Alicia
Nick
Elisabeth
Jerri
Maralyn
Jeff
Rodger
Amber
Kimmi
Debb
Kel
Mitchell
Colby
Keith
Michael

[TomC]

Originally Posted by MelihV

Debb was strange and annoying!

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by TomC

Debb was strange and annoying!

Debb was the most important cast member that season

[MB.]

I'm surprised Debb didn't rawk your world

[TomC]

I don't understand how the youths of Samburu can possibly be mad at the elders for giving their votes to Silas? The young ones are screwing the older ones over, like they had no reason not to tell them who was going, so there's no reason not for them to try and screw them as well

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by TomC

I don't understand how the youths of Samburu can possibly be mad at the elders for giving their votes to Silas? The young ones are screwing the older ones over, like they had no reason not to tell them who was going, so there's no reason not for them to try and screw them as well

still one of them was going to survive through the merge like planned 5-5 and that person could go very far and survive the young alliance when it came down to 5 of them because that alliance was shaky as ****. It was a very risky thing for older people to do that because at that point they only saw borneo and australia.

In those seasons there was no tribal switch and the tribe who got the adventage at the first tribal always made it to f3. But the people who had a rough start (Kelly 2nd Keith 3rd) had a very good chance at making far

[TomC]

Wow, I am so shocked that Silas got voted out by his tribe... Damn, he was hot too

[Braden]

Silas is one of the most beautiful men in the world.

[TomC]

Rankings after Episode 5:
1: Lindsey
2: Kelly
3: Brandon
4: Judy Murray (I genuinely can't remember her name?)
5: Teresa
6: Ethan
7: Clarence
8: Kim (has she had a second of airtime)
9: Tom (makes me laugh, but I don't appreciate the use of the word queer)
10: Lex
11: Frank

[TomC]

Nooooo not Lindsey! She was literally the most interesting character there! If only they hadn't done that bloody tribe swap That was a really good episode though, with Lindsey's moral conflict over who should go, when in fact she was the one in the firing line.

On a side note, I am really enjoying working my way through Survivor! I just love how each season is a little bit different, and there's something new each time, and I also look forward to All-Stars!

[reece(:]

Lindsey and Kelly top two <3

[MB.]

Glad we've got you hooked Tom

[TomC]

Originally Posted by MB.

Glad we've got you hooked Tom

It's such a great show!

Which seasons have returnees?

[MB.]

From Africa or in general? In general, 8, 11, 16, 20, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27 and 31

[TomC]

Originally Posted by MB.

From Africa or in general? In general, 8, 11, 16, 20, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27 and 31

In general, thanks

Lindsey gets a second chance right? Also, is it true Seasons 21-24 are quite bad?

[MB.]

The early-mid 20s are generally considered the worst, yeah, but that doesn't mean none of them are worth watching (25 in particular is widely thought to be a return to form, and even the suckier seasons of Survivor are pretty good by reality TV standards)

There haven't been many returnees from Africa recently, but as a first-time viewer I'm sure it'll be fun to find out as you go so I'll try not to spoil too much in that respect!

[TomC]

Originally Posted by MB.

The early-mid 20s are generally considered the worst, yeah, but that doesn't mean none of them are worth watching (25 in particular is widely thought to be a return to form, and even the suckier seasons of Survivor are pretty good by reality TV standards)

There haven't been many returnees from Africa recently, but as a first-time viewer I'm sure it'll be fun to find out as you go so I'll try not to spoil too much in that respect!

Yeah that's what I thought tbh. I'm looking forward to seeing who's in All-Stars when I get there!

I know Sue makes an appearance.

[MB.]

Micronesia

Tracy
Cirie
Jason
Eliza
Kathy
Ami
Natalie
Parvati
Chet
Alexis
Amanda
Erik
Yau-Man
Penner
Mikey B
James
Jonny Fairplay
Mary
Joel
Ozzy

[JerseyWins]

Yeah even though I find plenty of the people left to be kinda entertaining on their own, Redemption Island (the twist and the season in general) just isn't doing it for me. I'm slacking pretty badly on it. Tried to get some more watching in now but I'm giving up after an episode.

[MB.]

Next comes Palau, aka The Wanda Shirk Experience + 37 other days

[JerseyWins]

Decided to get through the rest of Redemption Island tonight and I'm on the jury questioning during the finale now.

Phillip (while sounding like a whiny child): You sound like a whiny child!

Phillip Sheppard everybody.

I've found him pretty annoying at times (mainly the Stealth R Us code names / corporation bs - which is part of why I didn't like him much last time) but damn this guy cracked me up a lot through the season.

[JerseyWins]

Omg these have to be the two biggest goats taken to the end in Survivor history.

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by MB.

Next comes Palau, aka The Wanda Shirk Experience + 37 other days

QUEEN

[JerseyWins]

Redemption Island

Terrific final 6 or so IMO that resulted in a few quality final moments to end the season... it was a decently good season at first which died out through the middle & became predictable by the end but definitely had its moments with Phillip constantly acting a fool around camp. Also enjoyable to see Rob entertain while also completing an amazing game even if it made for a boringly predictable mid-to-end game with no power shifts. It makes me wish I saw all of Rob's seasons before seeing this one but oh well.

---(faves)---
1. Boston Rob
2. Stephanie
3. Russell
4. Phillip
5. Natalie
---(liked)---
6. Ashley
7. Grant
8. Krista
---(ok)---
9. Andrea
10. Matt
11. Ralph
12. Francesca
---(meh)---
13. Sarita
14. Kristina
---(disliked)---
15. Steve
16. Mike
17. Julie
18. David

I'm tired and I also had a long gap between watching episodes so it's sort of tough to think back but I'd go with something like that for a cast ranking.