[Joelle.]

The girl groups have a reputation of being crap on the X Factor but which one would you say is the worst ever?

[Shaun]

Girlband were pretty poor...

[Legend killer]

One Direction

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

One Direction

[Stacey.]

Addictiv Ladies.

Seriously they were nothing.

I loved Voices With Soul, The Conway Sisters and Hope!

[Maia]

Girl Band.

Who dare vote Bad Lashes?

[MTVN]

Cant remeber most of them by name; they all got voted out too early I remember Miss Frank really annoyed me though.

[Kerry]

I too can't remember most. I thought Husstle were going to be great but like Simon said, it's one singer and 4 others randomly humming

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

I too can't remember most. I thought Husstle were going to be great but like Simon said, it's one singer and 4 others randomly humming

Still, 4 girls humming is better than 4 girls doing nothing at all - which is basically what the pussycat dolls are, backing dancers for miss scherzinger.

[Kerry]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

Still, 4 girls humming is better than 4 girls doing nothing at all - which is basically what the pussycat dolls are, backing dancers for miss scherzinger.

Aye. Suppose all 5 can never be the front runners either. Not many groups manage to have all their members be popular. But I think the blonde punky front girl in Husstle would be better solo

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

Aye. Suppose all 5 can never be the front runners either. Not many groups manage to have all their members be popular. But I think the blonde punky front girl in Husstle would be better solo

Yep she would be better solo, so would Nicole scherzinger. If they are the only ones who sing, what is the point in having the band at all.

[Z]

Girl Band... they were terrible.

[Mystic Mock]

hope.

[Niamh.]

ok did a bit of youtubing it was a tough choice between Hope and girlband but I went for Hope

[joeysteele]

Hope, who from the start really needed the extension 'less' added to their name.

[IheartBB]

I can't remember anything about Girl Band except for their lame attempt at a catchy name.

Belle Amie may go the same way too. I can't remember anything about them except for the fact they were thrown together at the last minute. Hopefully the live shows will change my mind.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Hope, who from the start really needed the extension 'less' added to their name.

Originally Posted by IheartBB

I can't remember anything about Girl Band except for their lame attempt at a catchy name.

Belle Amie may go the same way too. I can't remember anything about them except for the fact they were thrown together at the last minute. Hopefully the live shows will change my mind.

I thought they were really good, like a group that had been together for a while unlike the thrown together boys

[joeysteele]

Niamhxo, they were chronic though, weren't they.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Niamhxo, they were chronic though, weren't they.

seriously bad yeah. What do you make of Belle Amie? I think they could smash the dreaded girl band reputation, I don't think they'll win but I think they'll go farther than other girlbands have

[joeysteele]

I agree, its just it seems that a girl group is never really going to ever get enough overall support to compete properly with the other acts.
This time since Louis has a really weak list,it may be 'belle amie' are not the ones who get overlooked so early in the live shows.
Of course if Cher and Katie keep standing there doing nothing,expecting to get byes through to the next show then maybe anything can happen this year.

At this moment, for me it should be between Rebecca and Matt to win it though.

[Jords]

Girlband, Bad Lashes going against them was truely shocking!

[Tom]

I forgot all about Voices with Soul, they were really good

[Stephanie]

Originally Posted by Tom

I forgot all about Voices with Soul, they were really good

my mum knows one of them :L

[BB_Eye]

I remember the Conway Sisters being particularly bad.

[Adamw92]

The Conway Sisters, Kandy Rain and Bad Lashes