[Niamh.]

Just turned on Ep. 1 @Ammi @Cherie @bots ??

Youtube video

[Vanessa]

I was reading about this on facebook. I think she was trafficked.

[Cherie]

One for me for sure once I am finished my current watch

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

I was reading about this on facebook. I think she was trafficked.

Has that been confirmed?

[LaLaLand]

Binged this.

I was all for thinking she’d fell or, God forbid, jumped from the ship until the photograph of the escort. It does really look a lot like her and it makes me think “if it’s not her then who is it!?” - surely someone in all these years could have came forward and debunked that and say they know who that lady is (relative/friend etc) if it’s not Amy?

Also the Caribbean IP address lingering on the website dedicated to Amy on every birthday/anniversary etc. Spooky.

[Ammi]

…ahhhh, I’ve watched it…have you watched it all yet @Niamh. …?….

Spoiler:

…I’m not sure what to think, I’m very conflicted…I just can’t see how anyone could have got her off the ship so that she fell overboard is the obvious thing and makes the most sense…the IP address etc, I just don’t know because that’s hard to explain but if it was Amy then why would she be visiting that same site each time and not visiting current social media of her family as to following them now…I mean, she might be doing that as well…(…if it were her…)…but I don’t know, it just feels more trying to make it fit to feel she’s still alive and somehow they’ll be reunited…

[Ammi]

…ahhhh, I’ve watched it…have you watched it all yet @Niamh. …?….

Spoiler:

…I’m not sure what to think, I’m very conflicted…I just can’t see how anyone could have got her off the ship so that she fell overboard is the obvious thing and makes the most sense…the IP address etc, I just don’t know because that’s hard to explain but if it was Amy then why would she be visiting that same site each time and not visiting current social media of her family as to following them now…I mean, she might be doing that as well…(…if it were her…)…but I don’t know, it just feels more trying to make it fit to feel she’s still alive and somehow they’ll be reunited…

[Ammi]

…was Amy’s brother really named Brad Bradley…

[Ammi]

…I think…

Spoiler:

…what makes me think that she fell as well is that if a trafficking gang was involved then it was risky to choose someone who was travelling with her family and also she didn’t disappear in the evening when there was so much activity and drinking and partying going on etc…it was after she went back to the cabin and in a very small window of time, which doesn’t all fit for me…

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Ammi

…was Amy’s brother really named Brad Bradley…

I know, why would they do that???

I have about 20 mins of the final episode left, I'll finish it at lunchtime today

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I know, why would they do that???

I have about 20 mins of the final episode left, I'll finish it at lunchtime today

…ok, I have a dental check up this morning so if you can get your report to me this afternoon, that would be super……

[Ammi]

…also…

Spoiler:

…it’s not relevant to Amy’s disappearance but I’m intrigued as to the content of the three page letter that was sent to her partner by her father when Amy came out…

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

Has that been confirmed?

No just my thoughts after reading all the articles.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Ammi

…I think…

Spoiler:

…what makes me think that she fell as well is that if a trafficking gang was involved then it was risky to choose someone who was travelling with her family and also she didn’t disappear in the evening when there was so much activity and drinking and partying going on etc…it was after she went back to the cabin and in a very small window of time, which doesn’t all fit for me…

Spoiler:

But she went with a guy and was seen in an elevator that only staff uses. Apparently only
him came back up?

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by LaLaLand

Binged this.

I was all for thinking she’d fell or, God forbid, jumped from the ship until the photograph of the escort. It does really look a lot like her and it makes me think “if it’s not her then who is it!?” - surely someone in all these years could have came forward and debunked that and say they know who that lady is (relative/friend etc) if it’s not Amy?

Also the Caribbean IP address lingering on the website dedicated to Amy on every birthday/anniversary etc. Spooky.

The picture is definitely her. I'm 100% convinced.This is exactly why I don't go on cruises. People go missing in them all the time.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

No just my thoughts after reading all the articles.

If you're correct then that's horrible.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by LaLaLand

Binged this.

I was all for thinking she’d fell or, God forbid, jumped from the ship until the photograph of the escort. It does really look a lot like her and it makes me think “if it’s not her then who is it!?” - surely someone in all these years could have came forward and debunked that and say they know who that lady is (relative/friend etc) if it’s not Amy?

Also the Caribbean IP address lingering on the website dedicated to Amy on every birthday/anniversary etc. Spooky.

Spoiler:

Yeah, the eye witnesses who claim to have seen her, they may not be reliable, could be a different woman or they could just be making **** up for attention but that Photograph? That has to be her, I'd be very very sure that's the same person and back then photo editing wasn't like how it is today and you're right if it isn't Amy maybe the woman would have come forward or someone who knew who she is would?

Originally Posted by Ammi

…ahhhh, I’ve watched it…have you watched it all yet @Niamh. …?….

Spoiler:

…I’m not sure what to think, I’m very conflicted…I just can’t see how anyone could have got her off the ship so that she fell overboard is the obvious thing and makes the most sense…the IP address etc, I just don’t know because that’s hard to explain but if it was Amy then why would she be visiting that same site each time and not visiting current social media of her family as to following them now…I mean, she might be doing that as well…(…if it were her…)…but I don’t know, it just feels more trying to make it fit to feel she’s still alive and somehow they’ll be reunited…

Spoiler:

I actually am also listening to a podcast about the case, it's being released by the week though so I'm only one episode in but I trust the podcast more than the Netflix show because they can have an angle to push as well. So far with the podcast I'm leaning to her falling off the ship but they're pretty early on in the story so we'll see where my opinion ends up after the podcast is finished.

The eye witnesses would throw you off though but you can never tell how reliable these are, if those two women (who were teenagers at the time) are correct about seeing Amy go into the elevator with "Yellow" between 5:30am-6am then that imo sways the story in the direction of her getting off the boat. maybe Yellow did give her a contact to get drugs and she'd planned to go off the ship first thing and then find her parents after but she got snatched by those people?) I don't know, there is a lot of eye witness reports of seeing her though

regarding the IP address and website, maybe whoever it is looks at all the websites but they haven't done a what those website owners did digging through all the IPs?

Originally Posted by Ammi

…I think…

Spoiler:

…what makes me think that she fell as well is that if a trafficking gang was involved then it was risky to choose someone who was travelling with her family and also she didn’t disappear in the evening when there was so much activity and drinking and partying going on etc…it was after she went back to the cabin and in a very small window of time, which doesn’t all fit for me…

Spoiler:

maybe they think abducting someone from a cruise liner is a good way to go because everyone would think they fell or jumped from the ship?

[Niamh.]

I did think it was odd and a bit silly though

Spoiler:

That the people talking about the water searching were so sure that her body or part of her body or her clothes would have washed ashore had she fallen in the water. I was thinking if she'd gone in the water her body would probably never be found

[Niamh.]

Oh and can I just mention how much I disliked that Cruise director guy? and also the guy who claims to have spoken to her in the Brothel, serious creep vibes off that one

[caprimint]

This sounds so interesting, might watch it at some point

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by caprimint

This sounds so interesting, might watch it at some point

It's fascinating. I've been reading about it.
But it's really put me off going on a cruise.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by caprimint

This sounds so interesting, might watch it at some point

It's very intriguing definitely

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

The picture is definitely her. I'm 100% convinced.This is exactly why I don't go on cruises. People go missing in them all the time.

Spoiler:

When I was looking more online about the photo I found this article below, where there was a picture from the same ad and the girl in the photo is turned where you can see her shoulder and that Tasmanian Devil Tattoo that Amy had wasn't visible



https://www.ladbible.com/entertainme...12897-20250723

[Niamh.]

Ok after doing a bit of research I now believe that

Spoiler:

she either fell or jumped from the ship and that photo is not her :

Spoiler:

Been reading a few opinions I've come across online and people are right when they say human sex trafficking really doesn't work that way, kidnapping adult women from cruise ships from well off families, it's high risk and traffickers generally target vulnerable women in bad situations that they can groom and who don't have people they can contact to help them. It makes sense really.

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Spoiler:

When I was looking more online about the photo I found this article below, where there was a picture from the same ad and the girl in the photo is turned where you can see her shoulder and that Tasmanian Devil Tattoo that Amy had wasn't visible



https://www.ladbible.com/entertainme...12897-20250723

…although there are facial similarities, I never felt that this was Amy…