[Mystic Mock]

I promise to not make another thread like this for the next few days as I know that we've had quite a few of these threads lately (although I've personally enjoyed them) but I don't wanna drive people mad with them so I'll take a mini break after this thread.

Anyway TWD has had loads of main characters and side characters over the years so there are plenty of characters to choose from for your top 5 I feel.

Anyway my top 5.

1. The Governor
2. Herschel (I hope I've spelt that right)
3. Glenn
4. Alpha
5. Dale

[Ammi]

..of all time and in no particular order...


Shane
Beth
Morgan
Andrea
Maggie

[Lostie!]

1. Alpha
2. Dale
3. Shane
4. Dwight
5. Carol

[Cal.]

1. Andrea
2. Shane
3. Rosita
4. Carol
5. Beth

[Amy Jade]

1. Beth
2. Carol
3. Rosita
4. Dale
5. Michonne

[Strictly Jake]

Michonne
Negan
Rick
Carol
Beth

[Niamh.]

1. Shane
2. Andrea
3. Daryl
4. Carol
5. Ezekiel

[Toy Soldier]

1. Dog (obviously)
2. Judith
3. Carol
4. Negan
5. Daryl. But S1 - S4 and then again in S9... Couldn't stand him in S7/8 .

[Calderyon]

Only watched seasons 1 and 2 and some of the episodes of 3 so I cannot answer yet.

[reece(:]

Andrea
Dale
Michonne
Carol
Sasha

[Moniqua]

1) Sasha
2) Rosita
3) Connie
4) Carol
5) Michonne

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

I promise to not make another thread like this for the next few days as I know that we've had quite a few of these threads lately (although I've personally enjoyed them) but I don't wanna drive people mad with them so I'll take a mini break after this thread.

Nothing wrong with generating some discussion Mocky

Make as many as you please

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

1. Dog (obviously)
2. Judith
3. Carol
4. Negan
5. Daryl. But S1 - S4 and then again in S9... Couldn't stand him in S7/8 .

Oh if we count animals replace my list with

1. Tabitha
2. Dog
3. The horse from episode 1
4. The horse that bucked Daryl
5. The dogs that tried to eat Negan

[Natalie.]

Glenn
Shane
Andrea
Carol
Rosita

[JerseyWins]

Off the top of my head in no order (besides #1) I’d say:

Shane, Beth, Daryl, Glenn, Rosita. The Gov & Andrea were great too.

Bottom 5:

Rick, Carl, Carol, maybe Abraham, & maybe Sasha(? Can’t remember if that’s her name) or Eugene

[JerseyWins]

Negan also seemed like a potentially really great villain but I stopped watching shortly after he got involved

[Toy Soldier]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Negan also seemed like a potentially really great villain but I stopped watching shortly after he got involved

TBH he became a cartoon character villain and is only interesting now that he's a more rounded character with some sort of Stockholm Syndrome.

[Niamh.]

Negan almost made me quit, top 5 TS, TOP 5????

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

Nothing wrong with generating some discussion Mocky

Make as many as you please

Thanks.

I'm enjoying these kinds of threads at the moment as it's breakaway from the real life stuff such as Brexit (I promise not to mention it on this thread again) but I'm enjoying reading people's opinions on this thread and the other threads like it so I hope that more replies and threads of a similar nature will happen.

[Toy Soldier]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Negan almost made me quit, top 5 TS, TOP 5????

Of the characters still in it, easily top 5, and honestly so many of the characters have been wafer thin... there's not a huge amount of competition. I mean, people are "sad" about deaths like Tara, Jesus and Enid but I swear S9 noobs have had more meaningful character development than all three combined the entire time they were on the show! I feel like Lydia is a better rounded character in 7 episodes than poor Tara in 7 seasons .

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

Oh if we count animals replace my list with

1. Tabitba
2. Dog
3. The horse from episode 1
4. The horse that bucked Daryl
5. The dogs that tried to eat Negan

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

Of the characters still in it, easily top 5, and honestly so many of the characters have been wafer thin... there's not a huge amount of competition. I mean, people are "sad" about deaths like Tara, Jesus and Enid but I swear S9 noobs have had more meaningful character development than all three combined the entire time they were on the show! I feel like Lydia is a better rounded character in 7 episodes than poor Tara in 7 seasons .

Well that's why 4 out of 5 of my top 5 are from S1

[Jordan.]

Andrea
Dwight
Maggie
Michonne (b4 Rick)
Beth

[DouglasS]

I stopped in season 7, but:

Hershel
Dale
Carol
Shane
Beth or Maggie (undecided between the sisters, I like them both, would give them joint 5th)

Character development was so strong in seasons 1-3, by season 5 you’d have each character get about 2 mins screenrime or be missing from many episodes in a row. And so obviously all of my characters have been present from at least season 2 onwards. They introduced FAR to many characters in season 4,5,6,7 for you to really care about any of them

[Ant.]

In no particular order:

1. Beth
2. Carol
3. Michonne
4. Rosita
5. Tara

Glenn and Maggie are definitely up there <3
and Enid
S9 Daryl >>>>. S4-8 Daryl and so I'm starting to like him more
I'm also really liking Connie, Magna, Yumiko, Alden (although he won't become a favourite anytime soon)
Sasha and Abraham were good too

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Off the top of my head in no order (besides #1) I’d say:

Shane, Beth, Daryl, Glenn, Rosita. The Gov & Andrea were great too.

Bottom 5:

Rick, Carl, Carol, maybe Abraham, & maybe Sasha(? Can’t remember if that’s her name) or Eugene

I was like "wow Jersey has some great taste!) at your top characters

and then you went and listed your bottom 5 like.... i've never seen an uglier opinion, and I've read RileyH's forum faves