[Billy]

Originally Posted by Tom

We have had 3 other girl bands when Louis hasn't had the groups, Simon had them both years.

Addictive Ladies or whatever they were called were shite

The Conway Sisters were crap and were in the bottom 2 every week

Hope were far more likable than Kandy Rain and they were in the bottom 2 every week as well

Its just girl bands on the show, nothing to do with Louis. No matter who got them, they would have been out in week 1.

If having Simon can't get some girl bands past week 3 without being in the bottom 2 then what hope does any other judge have?

Because both groups were crap, like you said. Hope had some momentum as well, but on the weeks they got put in the bottom two, they had crap performances. Kandy Rains performance was better than say Hope's Lady Marmalade yet they were in the bottom two because of the styling and the fact that Louis cant get song choices right.

Miss Frank and Kandy Rain had potential to be amazing, and had Cheryl or Dannii mentored them, we wouldnt havehad so strange song choices.

Bearing in mind that Kandy Rain actually received a standing ovation in their audition and hailed as the best girl group, and even Bad Lashes from last year recently done some sessions with DS, and their performances were epic.

Louis just cant manage girls.