[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Stephanie

patrick do we judge by song choice or 'performance'

Song choice.

If people want to base it on Performance too they could base it on the music video if they want.

But Song Choice is a must.

[Stephanie]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Song choice.

If people want to base it on Performance too they could base it on the music video if they want.

But Song Choice is a must.

but *some* judges judge on a made up performance of how they think the contestant done it.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Stephanie

but *some* judges judge on a made up performance of how they think the contestant done it.

Yeah I think this is what the argument was over last week.

And I got some messages about judges being biased when doing that.
I think the judges know that it upsets some contestants so in future Song Choice will be the main thing when it comes to voting/coments.

But if they do want to add realism by 'Performance' it should only be based on the Music Video as the Music Video should be picked by the contestants anyway of Youtube.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Yeah I think this is what the argument was over last week.

And I got some messages about judges being biased when doing that.
I think the judges know that it upsets some contestants so in future Song Choice will be the main thing when it comes to voting/coments.

But if they do want to add realism by 'Performance' it should only be based on the Music Video as the Music Video should be picked by the contestants anyway of Youtube.

I think this is a good idea Patrick, dont get me wrong, I didnt mind judges making up preformance comments, but its not fair when they like the song choice but put them in the bottom 2 because they say the preformance was crap. A bit like what David has done with me this round, but no point moaning about it anymore, its a forum game here for a good laugh