[Showstopper]

Originally Posted by Livia

If Josie wasn't a big girl things would have been different. She would not have been the non-threatening girl who jokes around and puts herself down. More girls would have voted for her and she'd have probably been out. Of course, if she was skinnier, John James would have probably taken exception to her and treated her like he treated Rachael. And Rachel. And Sunshine... etc.

Josie has never been up for eviction, so unless her looks would have changed peoples noms which I dont think they would, she definitely wouldnt be out

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Showstopper

Josie has never been up for eviction, so unless her looks would have changed peoples noms which I dont think they would, she definitely wouldnt be out

You can't say "she definitely wouldn't be out" because you simply don't know. You're assuming that her character would be the same as a size 10 as it is as a size 18, or whatever she is. And it wouldn't.

[Showstopper]

Originally Posted by Livia

You can't say "she definitely wouldn't be out" because you simply don't know. You're assuming that her character would be the same as a size 10 as it is as a size 18, or whatever she is. And it wouldn't.

I'm saying she was never up for eviction, which she wasn't. I'm also saying that since she was never even close to being up, I don't think her being a size 10 would have swung noms that much to change it

Yes I'm assuming her character would be similar as a size ten, and at the same time your assuming it wouldn't.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by Showstopper

I'm saying she was never up for eviction, which she wasn't. I'm also saying that since she was never even close to being up, I don't think her being a size 10 would have swung noms that much to change it

Yes I'm assuming her character would be similar as a size ten, and at the same time your assuming it wouldn't.

Yes, her character would have been different - she wouldn't have been able to keep playing the victim card - with the woah is me - poor fat, country bumpkin - who can't get her man!

[daniel-lewis-1985]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Yes, her character would have been different - she wouldn't have been able to keep playing the victim card - with the woah is me - poor fat, country bumpkin - who can't get her man!

God your weird

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by daniel-lewis-1985

God your weird

Not my fault or problem if you lack understanding!