[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Oh come on, you don't think the producers lumping her with the best category three years in a row has anything to do with it? Every year without fail she has received the best category...it's nothing to with whether she's a good judge or not...she's just had an easy ride. I like her but it is unfair that she is favoured so much by the producers.

Thats bollocks and very easy to claim AFTER THE FACT.

Alexandra was not a huge contender until the latter part of the series. Joe was not mentioned much for first few weeks either. You can underplay her role all you like but 2 wins on the trot clearly shows that she is doing something right.

Last year she only had Joe who was decent. The other two were stinkers. So how was that the best category?

Cheryl has been a huge success on Xfactor....for whatever reasons. She just has been. So these sudden claims that she's suddenly a crap judge are just ludicrous.

Just bitterness from those pissed that she didnt pick their faves. Well tough titties!