[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Jords

I dont hate her but shes a crap judge.

And dont forget a crap singer lol

[Mr XcX]

Gamu was fab!!

[cub]

There's still a chance Gamu will still get in.

[Zippy]

She's won the past two years so its a bit laughable calling her a crap judge!

They only need to pick ONE act that will win. 11 acts will ultimately be losers. Doesnt matter much whether they come 6th or 10th.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by cub

There's still a chance Gamu will still get in.

Sadly if it means going in Cheryl's group i would rather she didn't , Cheryl does'nt deserve to handle someone as talented as Gamu

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

She's won the past two years so its a bit laughable calling her a crap judge!

They only need to pick ONE act that will win. 11 acts will ultimately be losers. Doesnt matter much whether they come 6th or 10th.

the only reason she won was because she had the best catagories.

[cub]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

the only reason she won was because she had the best catagories.

I think that's correct.

I think Dannii has the best this year.

[Zippy]

Funny how both Cheryl and Megan Fox seem to generate a lot of hatred on forums.

Anybody would think that certain females and gay men were just flat out jealous of their stunning looks and ability to attract any guy. Then there's the geeky straight guys who know they dont stand a chance with such hot girls....so what better way to get revenge than to hurl insults and abuse at them on internet forums? Thereby undermining their power.

So which one are you, haters?

[Enid]

This is hilarious.

I have no idea what's going on and this is still hilarious.

I've hated Cheryl for years and you've all decided to catch up?

[30stone]

[MeMyselfAndI]

good she deserves it

[Legend killer]

Cheryl has disgraced geordies all over the world ,and sld be very ashamed of herself.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Funny how both Cheryl and Megan Fox seem to generate a lot of hatred on forums.

Anybody would think that certain females and gay men were just flat out jealous of their stunning looks and ability to attract any guy. Then there's the geeky straight guys who know they dont stand a chance with such hot girls....so what better way to get revenge than to hurl insults and abuse at them on internet forums? Thereby undermining their power.

So which one are you, haters?

Zippy that is some bollocks tbh!

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Zippy

She's won the past two years so its a bit laughable calling her a crap judge!

Oh come on, you don't think the producers lumping her with the best category three years in a row has anything to do with it? Every year without fail she has received the best category...it's nothing to with whether she's a good judge or not...she's just had an easy ride. I like her but it is unfair that she is favoured so much by the producers.

[Jords]

I am still gobsmacked she hasnt landed the groups yet, considering she is from GIRLS ALOUD.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Oh come on, you don't think the producers lumping her with the best category three years in a row has anything to do with it? Every year without fail she has received the best category...it's nothing to with whether she's a good judge or not...she's just had an easy ride. I like her but it is unfair that she is favoured so much by the producers.

Before the 2009 live shows the general concensus was that the over 25s and the girls were the strongest categories

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Oh come on, you don't think the producers lumping her with the best category three years in a row has anything to do with it? Every year without fail she has received the best category...it's nothing to with whether she's a good judge or not...she's just had an easy ride. I like her but it is unfair that she is favoured so much by the producers.

Thats bollocks and very easy to claim AFTER THE FACT.

Alexandra was not a huge contender until the latter part of the series. Joe was not mentioned much for first few weeks either. You can underplay her role all you like but 2 wins on the trot clearly shows that she is doing something right.

Last year she only had Joe who was decent. The other two were stinkers. So how was that the best category?

Cheryl has been a huge success on Xfactor....for whatever reasons. She just has been. So these sudden claims that she's suddenly a crap judge are just ludicrous.

Just bitterness from those pissed that she didnt pick their faves. Well tough titties!

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Thats bollocks and very easy to claim AFTER THE FACT.

Alexandra was not a huge contender until the latter part of the series. Joe was not mentioned much for first few weeks either. You can underplay her role all you like but 2 wins on the trot clearly shows that she is doing something right.

Last year she only had Joe who was decent. The other two were stinkers. So how was that the best category?

Cheryl has been a huge success on Xfactor....for whatever reasons. She just has been. So these sudden claims that she's suddenly a crap judge are just ludicrous.

Just bitterness from those pissed that she didnt pick their faves. Well tough titties!

Surely thats a contradiction? If she picked 2 stinkers that makes her judging crap!

[Jords]

She should have put the black geezer through, cant remember his name.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Thats bollocks and very easy to claim AFTER THE FACT.

Alexandra was not a huge contender until the latter part of the series. Joe was not mentioned much for first few weeks either. You can underplay her role all you like but 2 wins on the trot clearly shows that she is doing something right.

Diana and Laura were though. Alexandra went onto win because Diana and Laura left and she gave good performances...that's not down to Cheryl, is it? That's down to Alexandra and the public.

Originally Posted by Zippy

Last year she only had Joe who was decent. The other two were stinkers. So how was that the best category?

When I refer to 'category', I mean her entire top 6/8 at Judge's Houses. The Boys were definitely the strongest last year, even if she didn't pick the right 3 for the Live Shows. Daniel Fox, Ethan, Duane, Lloyd, Joe, Rikki - strong category. Only Simon's Over's could potentially have been a better category...so maybe I go back on that claim. But she definitely has the best again this year.

Originally Posted by Zippy

Just bitterness from those pissed that she didnt pick their faves. Well tough titties!

Not really...I actually think Cheryl is the only judge to have picked the right three this year.

[Jords]

Ethan and Duane! Cant believe she didnt pick them.

[Stephanie]

duane was epic.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Not really...I actually think Cheryl is the only judge to have picked the right three this year.

she's chosen to take risks by going with creativity over technical ability it seems to me. I think thats fair enough as it is called the Xfactor after all.

[Stephanie]

i thought she was right picking rebecca and i like katie, but turning down both gamu and treyc was madness. one of them should have at least been picked.

[Angus]

The irony is that if CC had auditioned for the x factor she would have got absolutely nowhere seeing as she doesn't have IT. She has average talent and is really in no position to judge the talent of others, especially someone like Gamu whose talent is superior to CC in every way. Methinks CC is a jealous cow.