[Vicky.]

Cher is absolutely useless. She cannot rap, her voice is average, and she looks like skeletore with eyelashes.

Gamu should be there instead of her. For cheryl to even consider putting this fail through to the live shows after what happened at judges houses...when she wouldnt even come back to try a THIRD time at a song she messed up (yeah, she had a bad throat, but she could have at least shown that she wanted to try)...is just ridiculous. What a pathetic judge she is this year.

[stewart64]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Cher is absolutely useless. She cannot rap, her voice is average, and she looks like skeletore with eyelashes.

Gamu should be there instead of her. For cheryl to even consider putting this fail through to the live shows after what happened at judges houses...when she wouldnt even come back to try a THIRD time at a song she messed up (yeah, she had a bad throat, but she could have at least shown that she wanted to try)...is just ridiculous. What a pathetic judge she is this year.

Gamu looked every bit like a cliche or someone trying to do a young Diana Ross in the Supremes in Stars in their Eyes. Cher is her own person and new, she should have been given the nod over a copy cat.

I worry her tiny body will not take it and snap, other than the health risks though, Cheryl was spot on. And that goes for Katie too.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Gamu looked every bit like a cliche or someone trying to do a young Diana Ross in the Supremes in Stars in their Eyes. Cher is her own person and new, she should have been given the nod over a copy cat.

If cher could sing, then I would agree. Yeah, originals over copies anyday. As it stands, she cant sing, forgets her words, and doesnt even try to sort it out when she screws up. And thinks she can rap, when it is just embarrassing to watch.

Noone else would have been put through after such a dreadful bootcamp/judges houses audition.

I still didnt see Gamu as a copy though...

[Thotmas]

Look just take her off the show. She's mentally unstable and will go into complete depression if she doesn't win.

Sense before money and ratings people!! Or does the unstable rule only apply to less "marketable" people?

[Thotmas]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Cher is her own person and new, she should have been given the nod over a copy cat.

.

Cher is not THAT original sorry.

[stewart64]

Originally Posted by Ithinkiloveyoutoo

Cher is not THAT original sorry.

Not really qualified to disagree, and quite a few acts do weird. But she stands out IMO.