[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Yea I agree completely.

tbh if Wagner got to the final, or, god forbid, even won the show, I think louis should be sacked, he doesn't take the show seriously at all, the past two years he's poven this by putting **** acts through over decent ones.

Why should Louis be sacked? All the judges played a part in Wagner getting to judges houses, and since the live shows it has been the public keeping him in :/

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Why should Louis be sacked? All the judges played a part in Wagner getting to judges houses, and since the live shows it has been the public keeping him in :/

Because Louis is the one stupid enough to put them into the live shows

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Because Louis is the one stupid enough to put them into the live shows

But all of them were stupid enough to put them through the auditions/bootcamp...

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

But all of them were stupid enough to put them through the auditions/bootcamp...

ok, well in general Louis is also a cunt, that enough of a reason?

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

ok, well in general Louis is also a cunt, that enough of a reason?

Last year I would have agreed...

Now it seems he and Dannii are the only honest judges

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Smithy

ok, well in general Louis is also a cunt, that enough of a reason?

Louis is the best judge there

Simon already got rid of him once and it didn't work without him. Dannii & Cheryl haven't appeared wih no noticable difference

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Last year I would have agreed...

Now it seems he and Dannii are the only honest judges

He thinks Wagner performs well, he's clearly as much a bull ****ter as Cheryl and Simon

Originally Posted by Tom

Louis is the best judge there

Simon already got rid of him once and it didn't work without him. Dannii & Cheryl haven't appeared wih no noticable difference

Louis is awful, the only reason it didn't work was because noone knew who Brian Friedman was

[Z]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

But all of them were stupid enough to put them through the auditions/bootcamp...

Just Simon and Louis really; I don't know where Wagner auditioned so Cheryl may have contributed - but Dannii had no say in him getting to the live shows at least. Who knows, maybe Simon even said no at Wagner's audition and he got outnumbered?

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Zee

Just Simon and Louis really; I don't know where Wagner auditioned so Cheryl may have contributed - but Dannii had no say in him getting to the live shows at least. Who knows, maybe Simon even said no at Wagner's audition and he got outnumbered?

Well use jedward (another joke act) as an example then

The majority (if not all...I dont remember) voted them through.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Smithy

He thinks Wagner performs well, he's clearly as much a bull ****ter as Cheryl and Simon

Louis is awful, the only reason it didn't work was because noone knew who Brian Friedman was

Louis is the most entertaining judge there is. It didn't work because there was no entertainment...

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Louis is the most entertaining judge there is. It didn't work because there was no entertainment...

Err, no thats complete and utter bollocks, Brian was axed because he didn't feel comfortable on the judging panel, and it's not like you'd know whether there was entertainment, he was axed prior to broadcast, so you can't judge whether he was entertaining or not.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Why should Louis be sacked? All the judges played a part in Wagner getting to judges houses, and since the live shows it has been the public keeping him in :/

Absolutely right Vicky, no reasom Louis should be sacked at all,It also seems the public like these acts like Wagner in the competition too.