[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by CherieB

What I didn't like about the sing off tonight was that it was judged on both nights performances whereas previous sing offs have been based just on the sing off itself.....sorry but people who vote on xfactor really need their heads testing, as with Tesco Mary last year who was voted off against Cher...and the following week they had lined Cher up to sing with Will I Am....that would have been good to watch Tesco Mary and Will I Am...lol ...the judges get the opportunity to manipulate the public vote and that is wrong...it should be whoever is bottom of the public vote.

No it shouldn't. It only takes one bad week in voting and one of the favourites who wouldn't normally be in the bottom could leave. That'd just cause even more complaining.

[Cherry Christmas]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

No it shouldn't. It only takes one bad week in voting and one of the favourites who wouldn't normally be in the bottom could leave. That'd just cause even more complaining.

well the public could complain all they like but end of the day the choice would be theirs and theirs alone...

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by CherieB

well the public could complain all they like but end of the day the choice would be theirs and theirs alone...

But it's not and never has been. Everyone who votes is aware it's the judges who get the final choice. If they don't agree with it and moan everything is a fix when they don't get the outcome they want then they shouldn't vote in the first place.

[Cherry Christmas]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

But it's not and never has been. Everyone who votes is aware it's the judges who get the final choice. If they don't agree with it and moan everything is a fix when they don't get the outcome they want then they shouldn't vote in the first place.

which is why I dont, never have, never will vote on xfactor because its all a sham, however if they changed it so the public did have control then it might be different, but what is the point in wasting money when the judges have the ultimate decision...up until the final it is madness to vote for anyone as they will manipulate to who they want...by all means vote in the final if your favourite is still there but up until then save your cash.