[Livia]

Edit: in reply to JHChrist reply to mine...

Yeah, it's a fine idea, although it's not the same to ask if you lived in Argentina would you still be British. The Islanders would be on their home land which would suddenly become foreign soil to them. And anyway, I'm sure if we floated the idea with the Argentinians I'm sure they wouldn't go for it. And what about Chile? Geographically the Falklands are as close to Chile as they are to Argentina, maybe they'll be asking for a bit soon.

I'm sure if the Brits bent over backwards they still wouldn't be able to please all of the people all of the time. The fairest thing in my opinion is to ask the people who live on the islands, and whose families have lived on the islands for generations. Who could argue with that?