[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by 08marsh

If I was a middle aged singer or whatever I wouldn't be able to stomach being given critique on my vocals from a little girl who's been around all of 5 minutes.

If X Factor had any credibility to start with, they just lost it.

This. I'd never heard of her so had to look her up. Was a bit shocked to see she was only 19. Her age might cause some problems.

[BBfanUSA]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

This. I'd never heard of her so had to look her up. Was a bit shocked to see she was only 19. Her age might cause some problems.

actually the US version minimum is 12, Yes, 12. I would just laugh if she gets stuck with the over 30s (It's Boys 12-30, Girls 12-30, Groups, and Over 30s)
and yes they did have some 12-15 years old the first season (Rachel Crow 13, Drew of Girls Catergory 14, half of the manufactured group inTENsity, and Astro Boys catergory 15. And Rachel Crow was the last of them finishing 5th in controversal way.)