[sassysocks]

Originally Posted by alex_front2

Gary clearly never liked Nick but couldn't slate him for first month as he was singing in tune , just blandly. However once tptp gave him trickier songs and sabotaged production, Gary was able to stick boot in.

You do talk paranoid bull. Gary was quite supportive of Nicholas, when deserved -but critical when not - that is what a good judge is supposed to do. He was one of the few 'real' juges on the panel - hat off to him.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by sassysocks

You do talk paranoid bull. Gary was quite supportive of Nicholas, when deserved -but critical when not - that is what a good judge is supposed to do. He was one of the few 'real' juges on the panel - hat off to him.

If Gary was so "real" then how come he never criticized Sam Bailey for shouting in the final when only a couple of years ago he attacked Amelia for shouting in the sing-off when she clearly didn't?