[Ammi]

Originally Posted by y.winter

The "changing-shirt-becoming-someone-else" FX is not new on television, it has already been done in sports ads and included black/asian/white/latin people, metamorphosing into each other. It's always the same unity message of "we're all in this together, any kind of human being", and this was the same idea in the dove ad.
I find the whole drama around it very obnoxious and OTT (and I'm not surprised the screenshots were taken out of context). People need to calm down (and overall find better things to do online), not everything that includes white and black people is deliberately racist - some are, but not every little thing.

Originally Posted by Jamie89

I don't find it racist at all tbh, and I doubt it will have been a calculated move either, I don't know why they'd see it as a good way of creating a talking point, Dove are a huge brand and something like a racism controversy would only damage them, they know they'd be more at risk of losing sales than increasing them so that doesn't make sense to me. It was a 3 second Facebook ad not a large marketing campaign so it's likely that any racist connotations were overlooked as less people will have been involved in the approval of it, as well as the fact that people only seemed to make the racist connection after the ad was screenshotted and taken out of context and put into a seperate post so it's not as though those connotations were glaringly obvious anyway - It's something that had to be pulled apart in order to find something racist in it rather than the complaints coming naturally from the ad itself, as far as I can tell.

Reactions like this could actually make companies like Dove more wary about using people of different races in their campaigns in the future out of fear of unforseen backlash so the people who are complaining should think about that and the impact they themselves might be having on diversity by choosing to pick apart and criticise something just because there is a black person in it, when it clearly wasn't intended as racist.

...yeah I fairly much agree with winter an Jamie in that I don't find it racist...even watching the ad after it's obviously now been seen as racist, I still don't get it when I watch...I certainly don't think that it was an intentional thing from Dove, they have said not and detailed their concept to the models ...and there is no reason to feel they weren't being truthful/that feels way too 'conspiracy' ..I think it has just sadly been misinterpreted../unfortunately, sign of the times as Arista would say...