[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Yet you weren't happy for Livia to not be offended on her own behalf, you insinuated she was speaking for all Jews? you can't have it both ways

Are you Livias official spokesperson now?...ok.

I haven't got it both ways...I never requested it both ways.

If you re read my post again you will see that I insinuated very strongly she did not speak for the entire Jewish community.

She was speaking for herself relaying a story in relation to a situation she found herself in that (for me at least) inferred that if there was no intent there was no offence to be taken...That of course is entirely subjective and relies on the circumstances surrounding to two scenarios.

The inference was that is she wasn't offended at that why was Mr Gumede offended at this, how else is her comment to be interpreted?