[Kizzy]

The psychological aspect is one issue, however the percentage affected by that will be nothing in comparison to the percentage who just overeat and don't exercise.

[Kizzy]

Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?
Do they all have pyschological issues? If I ask for a ham sandwich I want a slice of ham between 2 slices of bread.
Not half a pig in a 6ft baguette dipped in gravy....

[arista]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?
Do they all have pyschological issues? If I ask for a ham sandwich I want a slice of ham between 2 slices of bread.
Not half a pig in a 6ft baguette dipped in gravy....

Yes Size of any meal is Alarmimg.

I did take what I could not eat back to my Hotel , for later
My own doggy bag, pre planned.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?
Do they all have pyschological issues? If I ask for a ham sandwich I want a slice of ham between 2 slices of bread.
Not half a pig in a 6ft baguette dipped in gravy....

Not sure where you're going with that.

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Livia

Not sure where you're going with that.

It's a statement, it's not going anywhere.
Do you have a response to it?

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

It's a statement, it's not going anywhere.
Do you have a response to it?

No, I do not think all Americans overeat. I'm not sure that really needed answering though.

Just because big portions are served doesn't mean everyone eats like a pig. So long as you expend more calories than you take in you can eat what you like. And having one large portion of something a day is preferable to eating five packets of biscuits, half a loaf of toast with butter, some crisps, lots of chocolate, a takeaway and several cans of beer. Which is the kid of diet a lot of fat people have.

[Kizzy]

Suppy and demand, if people didn't want mega meals then they wouldn't provide them.
Establishments would be saving themselves a fortune too if they didn't pander to the overeaters. Let them go out and buy more food if thats what they want to do, businesses don't have a duty of care to chubbers
And I didn't say ALL Americans overeat did I?
Cheers for the nutritional info, appreciated.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

Suppy and demand, if people didn't want mega meals then they wouldn't provide them.
Establishments would be saving themselves a fortune too if they didn't pander to the overeaters. Let them go out and buy more food if thats what they want to do, businesses don't have a duty of care to chubbers
And I didn't say ALL Americans overeat did I?
Cheers for the nutritional info, appreciated.

No, you didn't say all American overeat, you asked me whether they do. You said "Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?"

If you ever go to the USA you will see that not all outlets serve their meals in buckets. If you eat at burger joints and fast food outlets then you will be overwhelmed with food. But then, not everyone eats fast food every day. The only people responsible for their obesity is the obese person themselves, regardless of portion size.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Livia

No, you didn't say all American overeat, you asked me whether they do. You said "Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?"

If you ever go to the USA you will see that not all outlets serve their meals in buckets. If you eat at burger joints and fast food outlets then you will be overwhelmed with food. But then, not everyone eats fast food every day. The only people responsible for their obesity is the obese person themselves, regardless of portion size.

Yes Some Eat Salads
and are Trim.

But all those Fat Americans
if they got a free gastric band
they would slim down more.


I am sure Kizzy will get to America

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by arista

Yes Some Eat Salads
and are Trim.

But all those Fat Americans
if they got a free gastric band
they would slim down more.


I am sure Kizzy will get to America

Arista there are these amazing things called tellyboxes... You can see what it is like to visit other countries without actually going.
I'm aware that not every single American is obese...haha.
If they were given the opportunity to have one I think most would take it. Even if say 2 thirds maintain a healthy weight due to this it will have a great impact on the US socially and economically.
It does need to be used with education to help them make healthy choices for themselves and their families in the future.
And if they have food issues then that may be easier to address post op, as those who still feel the need to gorge can be identified easier.

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Livia

No, you didn't say all American overeat, you asked me whether they do. You said "Is everyone prone to overeating in america then?"

If you ever go to the USA you will see that not all outlets serve their meals in buckets. If you eat at burger joints and fast food outlets then you will be overwhelmed with food. But then, not everyone eats fast food every day. The only people responsible for their obesity is the obese person themselves, regardless of portion size.

I know what I said livia thankyou. I have seen the food served at these outlets, that is why I raised the issue in this thread.
To return to the initial point, yes I think that gastric bands to those who have exaused other avenues of weightloss should be made available.