[Macie Lightfoot]

1. Borneo
2. Amazon
3. Pearl Islands
4. Heroes vs. Villains
5. San Juan del Sur
6. Panama
7. Micronesia
8. Gabon
9. Africa
10. Marquesas
---11. Kaoh Rong---
12. Vanuatu
13. Cagayan
14. Nicaragua
15. China
16. Philippines
17. The Australian Outback
18. Guatemala
19. Palau
20. South Pacific
21. Tocantins
22. Fiji
23. Blood vs. Water
24. Thailand
25. All-Stars
---26. Millennials vs. Gen X---
27. Worlds Apart
28. One World
29. Cambodia
30. Samoa
31. Caramoan
32. Cook Islands
33. Redemption Island

The finer details might change depending on the day, but something like this generally speaking. Kaoh Rong was fantastic and clearly a fluke, and Millennials vs. Gen X clearly followed as a direct sequel of Cambodia and held onto a lot of that season's flaws. Terrible season, this show is heading into a terrible direction, not excited for Game Changers, etc. I've already posted enough **** in the main thread.

[Macie Lightfoot]

1. Borneo
2. Amazon
3. Pearl Islands
4. Heroes vs. Villains
5. San Juan del Sur
6. Panama
7. Micronesia
8. Gabon
9. Africa
10. Marquesas
11. Kaoh Rong
12. Vanuatu
13. Cagayan
14. Nicaragua
15. China
16. Philippines
17. The Australian Outback
18. Guatemala
19. Palau
20. South Pacific
---21. Game Changers---
22. Tocantins
23. Fiji
24. Blood vs. Water
25. Thailand
26. All-Stars
27. Millennials vs. Gen X
28. Worlds Apart
29. One World
30. Cambodia
31. Samoa
32. Caramoan
33. Cook Islands
34. Redemption Island

Game Changers was.... okay! A looooot better than I was expecting, but I was expecting complete garbage to be fair. I find it in the same vein of Blood vs. Water where it's just like "alright, this is another season of Survivor" and I don't feel that strongly about it either way I think the pre-merge was watchable but nothing special, and the post-merge got more boring by the episode, culminating in me falling asleep TWICE during the funale, which has never happened to me before (and I was definitely tired and in need of some sleep, but watching the finale didn't help at all.) I think #21 might actually be a little generous right now bc I'm thinking about Sandra, so don't be surprised if I bump this down like two or three spots sometime soon.

[DouglasS]

I'm shocked at howmuch I enjoyed this season, I also was expecting to not like it - I'm not massive on returnee seasons.

Pre-merge i thought was fantastic, some brilliant tribals. It was coherent in its editing as well to understand storylines and future plots.

I agree post merge was rushed, but I disagree that it was boring each episode - I think Debbie's elimination/Sarah's flipping was interesting to watch.

Also Zeke's elimination was a good episode, had no clue whether it'd be him, Andrea or Sierra.

I think it was actually a really good season, just messed up a bit from the rushed merge section, it really needed another episode - perhaps Cirie's boot episode. Which would have meant the finale could consist of Tai/Aubry's elimination and the goings of the camp.

Also the fact Sandra had the main edit of pre merge and then Cirie had the main edit of post merge was suprising, yet interesting. Also suprised Debbie was the villan of the season with such a strong edit, while Ozzy/Malcolm/JT didn't feature too much [Jeff's usual faves]. I personally do like Ozzzy/Malolm very much. Normally its very male dominated, so it was a nice suprise/change. I expected Hali/Sierra to have non-existant edits, but both actually featured pretty heavily.

[Macie Lightfoot]

1. Borneo
2. Amazon
3. Pearl Islands
4. Heroes vs. Villains
5. San Juan del Sur
6. Panama
7. Micronesia
8. Gabon
9. Africa
10. Marquesas
11. Kaoh Rong
12. Vanuatu
13. Cagayan
14. Nicaragua
15. China
16. Philippines
17. The Australian Outback
---18. Heroes v. Healers v. Hustlers---
19. Guatemala
20. Palau
21. South Pacific
22. Tocantins
23. Fiji
24. Blood vs. Water
25. Game Changers
26. Thailand
27. All-Stars
28. Millennials vs. Gen X
29. Worlds Apart
30. One World
31. Cambodia
32. Samoa
33. Caramoan
34. Cook Islands
35. Redemption Island

HvHvH was fine? For a season that definitely has something clearly wrong with it, it still manages to stay afloat and entertain pretty consistently because the cast is solid and the editing was very balanced and basically the entire endgame revolved around a bunch of absurd people having the most petty feuds imaginable and doing crazy things at camp and at TC and just generally thinking with their hearts and not with their brains IDK this forum was way too negative about this season just because Mike and lame ass Joe and ****ing DESI didn't succeed.

(I also bumped GC down a bit not bc it's aged poorly but it's forgettable? It's not bad but it almost feels like it didn't happen in some regards)

[reece(:]

1. China
2. Heroes vs Villains
3. Gabon
4. Micronesia
5. Pearl Islands
6. Panama
7. San Juan del Sur
8. Amazon
9. Philippines
10. One World
11. Cagayan
12. Nicaragua
13. Palau
14. Marquesas
15. Vanuatu
16. Borneo
17. Blood vs Water
18. Guatemala
19. Australia
20. Samoa
21. Worlds Apart
22. Tocantins
23. Africa
24. Caramoan
25. Cook Islands
26. Fiji
27. South Pacific
28. All-Stars
29. Redemption Island
30. Thailand

[reece(:]

1. China
2. Heroes vs Villains
3. Gabon
4. Micronesia
5. Pearl Islands
6. Panama
7. San Juan del Sur
8. Amazon
9. Philippines
10. Cagayan
11. Nicaragua
12. Koah Rong
13. One World
14. Palau
15. Marquesas
16. Vanuatu
17. Borneo
18. Blood vs Water
19. Cambodia
20. Guatemala
21. Australia
22. Samoa
23. Worlds Apart
24. Tocantins
25. Africa
26. Caramoan
27. Cook Islands
28. Fiji
29. South Pacific
30. Millennials vs Gen X
31. All-Stars
32. Redemption Island
33. Thailand

[LukeB]

Still Heroes vs Villians

1.Heroes Vs Villians
2.Micronesia
3.China
4.Pearl Islands
5.Panama
6.Amazon
7.San Juan Del Sur
8.Cagayan
9.Palau
10.All-Stars
11.Cook Islands
12.Australia
13.Blood Vs Water
14.Tocantins
15.Gabon
16.Marquesas
17.Guatemala
18.Nicaragua
19.Borneo
20.Caramoan
21.Redemption Island
22.Philippines
23.One World
24.South Pacific
25.Samoa
26.Worlds Apart
27.Thailand
28.Africa
29.Fiji
30.Vanuatu

[LukeB]

1.Heroes Vs Villians
2.Micronesia
3.China
4.Pearl Islands
5.Panama
6.Amazon
7.San Juan Del Sur
8.Cagayan
9.Palau
10.All-Stars
11.Cook Islands
12.Australia
13.Blood Vs Water
14.Kaoh Rong
15.Tocantins
16.Gabon
17.Marquesas
18.Guatemala
19.Nicaragua
20.Borneo
21.Caramoan
22.Redemption Island
23.Cambodia
24.Philippines
25.One World
26.South Pacific
27.Samoa
28.Worlds Apart
29.Thailand
30.Africa
31.Fiji
32.Vanuatu

[_Tom_]

Gabon, Pearl Islands and Micronesia are the Holy T <3

[Dominic]

aaand updating this

Amazon
Pearl Islands
Borneo
Gabon
Panama
China
Kaoh Rong
Palau
Africa
SJDS
Vanuatu
Philippines
HvV
Micronesia
Marquesas
Nicaragua
Cagayan
Australia
Thailand
BvW
Guatemala
Fiji
South Pacific
Tocantins
Worlds Apart
Cambodia
One World
All-Stars
Cook Islands
Samoa
Caramoan
RI

[JerseyWins]

I still have a whole bunch more seasons to go through but as of right now:

Cagayan for sure. Funny that it happened to be my first season watched (after watching Kaoh Rong live; technically Cagayan was the first season I finished).

Honorable mentions to:
San Juan Del Sur & Caramoan off the top of my head. There were some other really good ones as well. My most recently completed season, China, is high up there too.

[AarynGriesfan]

1. Survivor: Micronesia
2. Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains
3. Survivor: Blood vs. Water
4. Survivor: Pearl Islands
5. Survivor: The Amazon
6. Survivor: Cagayan
7. Survivor: Kaôh Rōng
8. Survivor: Tocantins
9. Survivor: The Australian Outback
10. Survivor: Borneo
11. Survivor: Philippines
12. Survivor: China
13. Survivor: Panama
14. Survivor: Vanuatu
15. Survivor: Cambodia
16. Survivor: Marquesas
17. Survivor: San Juan del Sur
18. Survivor: Africa
19. Survivor: Guatemala
20. Survivor: Palau
21. Survivor: Worlds Apart
22. Survivor: Gabon
23. Survivor: Redemption Island
24. Survivor: One World
25. Survivor: Cook Islands
26. Survivor: Nicaragua
27. Survivor: South Pacific
28. Survivor: Caramoan
29. Survivor: Samoa
30. Survivor: All-Stars
31. Survivor Thailand
32. Survivor: Fiji

[JerseyWins]

Also I forgot about Panama. Definitely top 5 and maybe as good as #2.

[hot2go]

Any that have finished airing

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by hot2go

Any that have finished airing

[MB.]

um okay

[Calderyon]

Still Heroes vs Villains.

[DouglasS]

I've not seen the first 10 or so seasons, I do plan on watching them eventually. I've also not seen the most recent season as Cambodia really put me off watching survivor, justice for Chaos Kass1

Micronesia

1] Micronesia [16]
2] Heroes v Villans [20]
3] Cagayan [28]
4] Blood vs Water [27]
5] Gabon [17]
6] Philipinnes [25]
7] China [15]
8] Pearl Islands [7]
9] Caramoan [26]
10] Samoa [19]
11] San Juan del Sur [29]
12] Cook Islands [13]
13] Kaoh Rong
14] Redemption Island [22]
15] Nicargua [21]
16] Panama [12]
17] One World [24]
18] World’s Apart [30]
19] Cambodia [31]
20] Tocantins [18]
21] Fiji [14]


Seasons not seen; 1,2,3,4,5,6,8,9,10,11, 23

[reece(:]

You haven't seen San Juan del Sur?

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by reece(:

You haven't seen San Juan del Sur?

Is that Blood vs Water 2? Post Merge one of my favourite seasons ever, great TV. Pre-merge really suffered though, It'd be in my top half of Survivor.

I haven't seen the most recent season, I'm not sure where it took place.

[LukeB]

1.Heroes Vs Villians
2.Micronesia
3.China
4.Pearl Islands
5.Panama
6.Amazon
7.San Juan Del Sur
8.Cagayan
9.Palau
10.All-Stars
11.Cook Islands
12.Australia
13.Blood Vs Water
14.Kaoh Rong
15.Tocantins
16.Gabon
17.Marquesas
18.Guatemala
19.Nicaragua
20.Millennials vs. Gen X
21.Borneo
22.Caramoan
23.Redemption Island
24.Cambodia
25.Philippines
26.One World
27.South Pacific
28.Samoa
29.Worlds Apart
30.Thailand
31.Africa
32.Fiji
33.Vanuatu

[caprimint]

Out of the seasons I've seen, S33 is my favourite so far. I know arguments can be made against the edit etc, but from a character/unpredictability point of view, it was brilliant and had some really interesting/entertaining moments.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by caprimincepie

Out of the seasons I've seen, S33 is my favourite so far. I know arguments can be made against the edit etc, but from a character/unpredictability point of view, it was brilliant and had some really interesting/entertaining moments.

I was meh at the season at first but started to enjoy it tbh. I wouldn't watch something I don't like all the way through and moan and moan about it if i didn't.

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by caprimincepie

Out of the seasons I've seen, S33 is my favourite so far. I know arguments can be made against the edit etc, but from a character/unpredictability point of view, it was brilliant and had some really interesting/entertaining moments.

Yes Sooooo many moments. Beautiful moments between the Zeke/Bret moment and the one with Jay/Adam about Adam's mom. Also, the family visit was one of the best visits ever IMO from an emotional standpoint, although in fairness they really dragged it on with there being 9 or so people left in the game. More importantly, there were so many game moments during the season followed by insane tribal council after insane tribal council. Paul getting taken down early and David/Ken going from the bottom to the top, Michaela's blindside, just as some early examples (as much as I liked her it was a great moment where she shined and since she returns anyway I think it's fine). It only got crazier later in the season. As much as people want to say it was a predictable season with a predictable winner; well in the end it really wasn't since not many picked Adam to win. IMO the results were simply wild throughout the season, not just the winner. Many jurors/finalists had perfectly fine edits but some will be irrelevant, it happens on every season. What I'll say is the editors could've edited in some storylines a little better like the Sunday/Jessica rivalry and maybe include a few more main characters than they did.

I'm no hater of Kaoh Rong at all but MvGX is right on its level if not better. Many will disagree but there was a better boot order in MvGX as well. A lot of my faves went out early in Kaoh Rong (although I was still able to like a decent amount of people around the end anyway) but in MvGX a lot of my faves remained.

[Macie Lightfoot]

and yet I'm the one with no life trying to start an argument