[Patrick]

Who would you rather be your Mentor and why?

Dont neccesarly think of your favourite judge, try and think of who would give you the best Songs, and who has had the most success with acts..

[Chels]

Simon cus he tends to know what he's doing a bit more than the others.

[biglover]

I would like Simon, becuase you have more chance of international success with him than an of the others.

[Beastie]

Louis! and I would want to be in a group!

[LemonJam]

Definatley Simon.

[Jords]

I choose Dannii as I like her as a person, and shes the better judge and mentor.

But I wouldnt mind Cheryl, she looks good ok And Simon as he would make good choices.

Louis I would dread!

[CiaraD]

As long as it wasn't Louis :P

[Beastie]

Originally Posted by Jords

I choose Dannii as I like her as a person, and shes the better judge and mentor.

But I wouldnt mind Cheryl, she looks good ok And Simon as he would make good choices.

Louis I would dread!

Do you want to lick Cheryl's bottom hole?

[CaraRawr]

Dannii or Simon.

[Raph]

I voted Dannii, because I would like a mentor who actually cares. I don't mind if I have to face the unfair mentor, Simon, as I would like to think I'd be much happier coming 4th or 5th out like Rachel or Lucie than still be in because of Simon's tactical voting <3

and Dannii is just the coolest

[Braden]

i voted dannii
because she is the more caring judge,
who makes good decisions.

[aiv]

Louis
I have a feeling that he'll be extra nice to me because I'm Irish :P
I'm a worse singer than John minus Edward and that's saying something so getting through in the X Factor would never happen for me, I wouldn't have the guts to do it anyway!
I wouldn't mind which mentor really as long as I didn't get Dannii

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

Definatley Simon.

Actually, having thought about it, I'd prefer to sing rock type music and I think Dannii can accept peoples taste and lets them sing what they want where as Simons more 'This is what I've chosen for you, do it.' So I change my answer to Dannii.

[Princess]

Dannii because she treats her contestants as people rather than as artists who could make her loads of money. She does what's best for them and let's them contribute,plus she's lovely and constructive.

[Stephanie]

dannii

[xDramatick]

Dannii, she's the only one who comments on vocals, and is really good at holding onto her acts [Series 4 - 2 in the final, Series 5 - took all three to the sixth week, Series 6 - last act standing has a chance of winning]. I also think she's the only one who gets really personal with them, and gives great song choices.

[Christina]

Probably Simon but i'd love it to be Danni tbh, she has loadsa fun with her acts.

[Tom]

Dannii

Cheryl is hopeless, Louis only puts through one good one and stitches the rest up and Simon is too busy jetting to and from America to really get involved

[mizzy25]

cheryl as she chooses songs well

[Z]

In previous series' it would have been Simon but Dannii's pretty much wiped the floor this series. She cares for her acts, she's a fair judge and she seems to really get to know her acts and be their friend as well as their mentor.

[Adamw92]

Dannii! she is the best mentor

[Firewire]

Cheryl. I would.

However I chose Dannii because she has been a fantastic judge this season.