[Stevep]

This has most likely been asked before but as i havent seen one myself ill post one again.

Dont dislike any tbh, Cheryl gets on my nerves at times as i feel she is a bit of a Diva e.g has a bit of an attitude on occasions aswell as throws a strop when things dont go her way or people dont agree with her. But again thats only a small thing and i dont dislike her for it but it is a fault.

I'd go:

1. Dannii
2. Simon

[Lee.]

Simon definitely! He makes me laugh, talks sense, is ALWAYS right... and, erm is kinda hot

[Vicky.]

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

Louis WAS my least fave until Cheryls embarassing performance this year

[Stacey.]

Louis. He's the funniest by far, and I like listening to what he has to say.

1. Louis
2. Cheryl
3. Simon
4. Dannii

[MTVN]

1.Louis

2.Simon



3.Cheryl







4.Dannii

[Jords]

Dannii!

[Jevans]

Dannii and Louis however can only vote one so Dannii. Shes not credited enough

[red]

Louis ,he's a leg-end!!

[Shaun]

1. Dannii - the only one willing to give constructive criticism. She speaks her mind and is generally a nice person.
2. Louis - great entertainment, total nutcase, makes a few ridiculous decisions and comments, but is otherwise good comedy. Would never want to meet/speak to him, though.
3. Simon - used to be my favourite by a clear mile - but he has contradicted himself far too often: Diva Fever, after his anti-Jedward stance last year? He also wildly exaggerates the contestants' 'talent' - all this 'world class' BS. Please. They're tailored for Butlins, nothing more.
4. Cheryl - she was supposed to be the relevant new addition - but if what's relevant entails indecisive arselicking then I'd rather be irrelevant. She's hopeless. Afraid to criticise (and even more so now because of the Gamu incident), she's the most vacuous and bland person you could ever have to guide you through the music industry. She strikes me as a very lovely person, but that just doesn't cut it.

[Smithy]

Dannii >>>>>>>>>>>> the rest

[Tom4784]

Dannii, the rest have succumb to the theatrics of it all and rarely give constructive criticism.

[Jordan.]

Dannii > Simon > Cheryl > Louis.

[_Seth]

Louis, even though he's a right freak. XD

[Braden]

Dannii Minogue <3333

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

lol @ simon with no votes

[Jack_]

In terms of the best Judge:

#1 - Dannii
#2 - Simon
#3 - Louis
#4 - Cheryl

In terms of who provides the most entertainment:

#1 - Simon and Louis
#2 - Cheryl and Dannii

In terms of who did provide the most entertainment and should return to the panel:

#1 - Sharon

Overall:

#1 - Simon
#2 - Louis
#3 - Dannii
#4 - Cheryl

[Saph]

louis and Danii are the only judges who actually say their opinion.

Simon is to soft now and Cheryl just says what Simon wants her to say.

[MTVN]

Too much love for Dannii

Simon's been doing this for years and has been hugely succesful in the music industry and in these competitions in particular
Louis is the same with a few big acts to his name
Cheryl has been through this whole process before and knows what they're going through

Dannii, on the other hand, is famous purely for her surname.

[Mystic Mock]

i voted simon because he has a dry humour.

[Patrick]

You people are f--ked up.

1. Simon - Tells it how it is and is funny
2 Cheryl - Sexy and is funny.
3 Louis - Utter Fail but god he's hilarious at failing
4 Danni - Great Judge but abit boring but deffo the best judge.

[Joelle.]

Louis is hilarious but is a right idiotic mug.
Dannii is a lovely person and gives them good constructive criticism.
Simon is obviously a legend and speaks his mind always.
Cheryl I used to like but she has recently resorted to poor decision making and arselicking Simon and the acts.

[joeysteele]

Simon really knows what he is talking about so he cannot be faulted, Louis I would put close to him because I love Louis humour.
Dannii is always constructive in her comments.
Cheryl is false, pure and simple, false.

[bbfan1991]

Louis- He's hilarious, I enjoy listening to what he says even though he can be a right muppet.. knows what he is talking about and is a nice man just filling a panto judge role.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Simon really knows what he is talking about so he cannot be faulted, Louis I would put close to him because I love Louis humour.
Dannii is always constructive in her comments.
Cheryl is false, pure and simple, false.

I used to think the same of Simon up until the last few years. He's a joke now.

Danni is constructive in her comments but destructive in how she styles her contestants and with song choices. Far too often she fecks it up.

Cheryl is totally false... can't stand her.

Louis is an eejit, but an entertaining one. Best thing about the show at the moment.

[stewart64]

Cheryl because she could have taken the easy option over Gamugate, she even had the wild card to appease Gamu's fans, but she did what she thought was right even though she was risking her popularity (and has put a big dent in it).