[Urban Cragou]

What’s your favourite Big Brother series of the four standout ones - BB3 or any one of the mid.-noughties ones?

[ChristmasNeeve]

BB3 but I would have gone for BB2 if it had been an option

[MB.]

6 > 5 >> 7 > 3

[Epic.]

Originally Posted by MB.

6 > 5 >> 7 > 3

/thread

[Dogeatdog]

BB6

[Shaun]

6 > 5 >>>>> 3 >>(13) >> (18) > 7

[Peppermint]

BB12

[Urban Cragou]

I’d say the seventh series was the start of the exploitation of very vulnerable people and no other series had such a string of those types but there’s no denying it was an entertaining series.

[UserSince2005]

5>6>3>7

[Urban Cragou]

Originally Posted by Shaun

6 > 5 >>>>> 3 >>(13) >> (18) > 7

You don’t rate 7 at all?

[Captain.Remy]

5>6>C4/C5 series>>>>>>>>>>BB7

[DouglasS]

7

Easily the best

6 is the worst

[UserSince2005]

Anyone who thinks 7 is the best it was clearly their first series and therefore they are bias

[Time to Sleigh]

5-6-7 in that order but liked all. Just wish charley had been in 6 rather than 8!

[Shaun]

Originally Posted by Redway

You don’t rate 7 at all?

I've said it somewhere before but basically I think it's only so revered because of nostalgia. 2006 was a great year, one of my favourites, and everyone looks back on BB7 as the Nikki, Aisleyne series... but really, aside from those two housemates, how many actually stand out? A good 50% of the cast had minimal impact.

I might be too harsh in retrospect but I just think it's something that every time I've caught clips of rewatches or whatever, it was largely a big, boring clique that picked off the eccentric housemates one by one.

[Captain.Remy]

Originally Posted by Shaun

I've said it somewhere before but basically I think it's only so revered because of nostalgia. 2006 was a great year, one of my favourites, and everyone looks back on BB7 as the Nikki, Aisleyne series... but really, aside from those two housemates, how many actually stand out? A good 50% of the cast had minimal impact.

I might be too harsh in retrospect but I just think it's something that every time I've caught clips of rewatches or whatever, it was largely a big, boring clique that picked off the eccentric housemates one by one.

ANd that's why it was one of the worst for me tbh

[Daniel.]

Originally Posted by Shaun

I've said it somewhere before but basically I think it's only so revered because of nostalgia. 2006 was a great year, one of my favourites, and everyone looks back on BB7 as the Nikki, Aisleyne series... but really, aside from those two housemates, how many actually stand out? A good 50% of the cast had minimal impact.

I might be too harsh in retrospect but I just think it's something that every time I've caught clips of rewatches or whatever, it was largely a big, boring clique that picked off the eccentric housemates one by one.

I can only imagine you mean Richard/Susie picking off the eccentric ones, as the other grouo mainly went early

[Urban Cragou]

Originally Posted by Shaun

I've said it somewhere before but basically I think it's only so revered because of nostalgia. 2006 was a great year, one of my favourites, and everyone looks back on BB7 as the Nikki, Aisleyne series... but really, aside from those two housemates, how many actually stand out? A good 50% of the cast had minimal impact.

I might be too harsh in retrospect but I just think it's something that every time I've caught clips of rewatches or whatever, it was largely a big, boring clique that picked off the eccentric housemates one by one.

This is a wide bump but how do you feel last year’s series measures up to BB7, a series you have somewhat ambivalent feelings about but can probably recognise is better than most of what followed at-least, even if on its own merit it wasn’t to your liking, with those isolated spikes of eccentricity providing most of the entertainment and not always for the better?

I’ve said before that I personally think last year was the best since BB7, if we-gon. hold down BB7 as a blueprint for decent, if not always tasteful, quality, and the vibrancy of housemates just wasn’t matched this year, so naturally I barely followed this one just-gone. Maybe it’s for precisely that reason that I’m missing some key context, maybe, for this year’s contestants but I dunno. I dunno. I know what I like and this year wasn’t it.