[daniel-lewis-1985]

Originally Posted by Livia

Obviously no one can tell what someone will be like because nothing in life is black or white. We both know that. But I'm saying, having experienced people who have slimmed down and people who have bulked up, their character changes.

Deliberately being obtuse, much?

You said she WOULD change if she lost weight. And now your contradicting yourself by saying noone knows if she would change.

Also you said when i mentioned Sophie Reade that it wasnt relevant to the topic as we are talking about Josie not Sophie, and now your comparing Josie to someone else.

You are the definition of contradiction