[MattBlake]

well Simon.
not the other three, cause they're fair and honest

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by MattBlake

well Simon.
not the other three, cause they're fair and honest

How is Simon not fair?
He took it to the Public vote which is very fair.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MattBlake

well Simon.
not the other three, cause they're fair and honest

For the love of God will you get.over.it.

Simon made the fairest choice and that's it.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by Jack_

For the love of God will you get.over.it.

Simon made the fairest choice and that's it.

Of course he didn't. He's often stated that it's about singing talent and that the sing off is where you have to prove your worth. And don't forget also that he's been saying all along that Lloyd has only survived because of his looks.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by setanta

Of course he didn't. He's often stated that it's about singing talent and that the sing off is where you have to prove your worth. And don't forget also that he's been saying all along that Lloyd has only survived because of his looks.

This^^^^

I would like that part of the show if they stuck to the rules and judged them on their performances like they're supposed to do. If they're going to decide not to do this whenever it suits them then it's unfair and rule should just be done away with and let the public decide all the time!!

[setanta]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

This^^^^

I would like that part of the show if they stuck to the rules and judged them on their performances like they're supposed to do. If they're going to decide not to do this whenever it suits them then it's unfair and rule should just be done away with and let the public decide all the time!!

Do you think he would have put it to deadlock if John and Edward were up against Rachel? It's a joke of a show now.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by setanta

Do you think he would have put it to deadlock if John and Edward were up against Rachel? It's a joke of a show now.

Of course not!

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by MattBlake

well Simon.
not the other three, cause they're fair and honest

Simon is the only judge there that would be honest enough to send his own act home if he thought they hadn't got what it takes,he has told his acts before if he hasn't thought they were good,the others will always save their own no matter what as most of us know Louie would do just that if J&E were in the bottom two and they clearly are not the best singers,don't know why people slag Simon of if it wasn't for him,X Factor wouldn't exist along with BGT etc,you all enjoy these programs,so why slag the creator off?Simon is the best judge,he doesn't sugarcoat things just to curry favour with the public,they say he truth hurts,maybe that's why people don't like him!

[setanta]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Simon is the only judge there that would be honest enough to send his own act home if he thought they hadn't got what it takes,he has told his acts before if he hasn't thought they were good,the others will always save their own no matter what as most of us know Louie would do just that if J&E were in the bottom two and they clearly are not the best singers,don't know why people slag Simon of if it wasn't for him,X Factor wouldn't exist along with BGT etc,you all enjoy these programs,so why slag the creator off?Simon is the best judge,he doesn't sugarcoat things just to curry favour with the public,they say he truth hurts,maybe that's why people don't like him!

So by creating it he's exempt from criticism? He sent his own act home about 3 years ago.... we're discussing the here and now, where he's proven on numerous occassions that his judgement is purely based on his own selfish motivations.