[tate]

Personally i dont like the woman for many reasons but i do not let that cloud my judgement however to mime on a show where you are critical of other people's live singing i think is bang out of order

Unfortunately I dont think she has talent in the singing department however she does put on a show (like Madonna etc mentioned above who are not great vocalists either) but on a show like this where you have 4 girls looking up to you and taking your advice and then other acts who you have the option to be critical of then I think she should have sung live as they have to each week

If you need to mask your lack of vocal talent on a primarily vocal talent show by clouding it with dancers and lightening sets then this should not be showcased on a show like this - it certainly leaves you open to abuse (as i see in the papers today) and i would have thought that after last year's miming debate she would have thought better of doing it again - then again, owt for publicity eh Chezza?