[Ammi]

Originally Posted by tate

Personally i dont like the woman for many reasons but i do not let that cloud my judgement however to mime on a show where you are critical of other people's live singing i think is bang out of order

Unfortunately I dont think she has talent in the singing department however she does put on a show (like Madonna etc mentioned above who are not great vocalists either) but on a show like this where you have 4 girls looking up to you and taking your advice and then other acts who you have the option to be critical of then I think she should have sung live as they have to each week

If you need to mask your lack of vocal talent on a primarily vocal talent show by clouding it with dancers and lightening sets then this should not be showcased on a show like this - it certainly leaves you open to abuse (as i see in the papers today) and i would have thought that after last year's miming debate she would have thought better of doing it again - then again, owt for publicity eh Chezza?

I agree with you, I don't have a problem with her miming as other artists do but imo she should seperate her role as an Xfactor judge with promoting her own solo career and just not perform on the XFactor. It does her no favours as it leaves her performance open to critisism and alienates part of the public that switch on for the XFactor contestants not to pay homage to Cheryl Cole