[Tom]

Originally Posted by Shaun

I do think it's quite silly having themes at all - it'd make much more sense to just have any song they want, and no judges - but I guess that it would just be Pop Idol then

Vague themes are good, and it was good when they first started the themes and had a relevant artist on each week e.g. Motown week with Lionel Richie whereas now its a bit more random

And dont you mean Stars in their Eyes? ... that was loads better anyway

I hated Matthew Kelly though