[Jack_]

...instead of the normal covers they do. I've had the idea before but after seeing this on a music channel earlier it reminded me:

Youtube video

Classic.

Or if not have the winner's single as a Christmas song. Thoughts?

[Mystic Mock]

i agree as i think a christmas charity single would be a huge hit.

[Patrick]

I'm a Yeo Valley for Christmas #1 2010 Supporter you see, but if the winner's song was to be Christmassy, it would be the first time in about 10 years we got a Christmas Song as Christmas Number 1, It still bugs me why the ******ing dolts behind last year's 2009 Campaign didn't pick a good Christmas song rather than some vile American rockers.

But yes, If they were to release a Christmas Winners song I'd so support that rather than our Yeo Valley Campaign.

[Tom]

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Tom

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

Will Young is brilliant and still around too

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

Will Young is brilliant and still around too

I meant as a whole

A fair bit of the Pop Idol lot are still about e.g. Sam & Mark and Michelle McManus are doing TV presenting

[_Seth]

I thought they always did. Maybe not a Christmas charity single, but still one for charity.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Tom

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

Tomorrow to download, Monday physically. They're performing it tomorrow night.

Originally Posted by Phlip

I thought they always did. Maybe not a Christmas charity single, but still one for charity.

They do. But a Christmas charity single has never been done on X Factor - that's why I made the suggestion in this thread.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Tom

I meant as a whole

A fair bit of the Pop Idol lot are still about e.g. Sam & Mark and Michelle McManus are doing TV presenting

I remember Simon being so pissed off that Gareth Gates didn't win, that was the last time I voted on one of those shows. It shows that Simons eye for talent may not be as good as he thinks, Will did something after that is so unusual for a contestant from one of these shows, he's actually lasted more than a year

[Niamh.]

I think a Christmas song would be a great idea Jack