[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Glad I amuse you then

You have made my day

Its interesting that you replied to me and not to the two Jewish forum members who are challenging your views. Do you have anything to say on topic?

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Its interesting that you replied to me and not to the two Jewish forum members who are challenging your views. Do you have anything to say on topic?

I dont give a stuff about people challenging my views to be honest with you.

And who do you think you are, telling me who to reply to dear

Edit. And I only see angus' reply to me Which I have now answered anyways as I didnt read the bit on the end.

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I dont give a stuff about people challenging my views to be honest with you.

And who do you think you are, telling me who to reply to dear

I didnt tell you who to reply to I merely pointed out that you didnt post an on topic reply. I thought it was a fair point TBH not deserving your 'who the hell' response. You cant complain this thread is off topic as you are the one responsible for it being so.

On topic - I appreiate Galliano's right to freedom of speech but given what he said the sacking was justified given the negative effect it has had on the Dior name.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

I didnt tell you who to reply to I merely pointed out that you didnt post an on topic reply. I thought it was a fair point TBH not deserving your 'who the hell' response. You cant complain this thread is off topic as you are the one responsible for it being so.

On topic - I appreiate Galliano's right to freedom of speech but given what he said the sacking was justified given the negative effect it has had on the Dior name.

I did that where? :S

And also, you only added the 'on topic' bit on your other post as an afterthought, so I find it quite laughable that you are challenging me on replying to an offtopic post, with an offtopic answer. So you obviously have no real problem with offtopic posts, you are just wanting to moan at me. Which is also fine. As its YOUR right

Also, this wouldnt have even been took offtopic, if one FM hadnt decided to bring in something pretty irrelevant to THIS thread(as it was an off the cuff remark elsewhere, a while ago)...to try and make my opinion less valid. Funny how you blame me for someone else bringing in irrelevant arguments, eh?

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I did that where? :S

And also, you only added the 'on topic' bit on your other post as an afterthought, so I find it quite laughable that you are challenging me on replying to an offtopic post, with an offtopic answer. So you obviously have no real problem with offtopic posts, you are just wanting to moan at me. Which is also fine. As its YOUR right

Also, this wouldnt have even been took offtopic, if one FM hadnt decided to bring in something pretty irrelevant to THIS thread(as it was an off the cuff remark elsewhere, a while ago)...to try and make my opinion less valid. Funny how you blame me for someone else bringing in irrelevant arguments, eh?

I posted my other post before i finished it. The on topic part was always part of it. Trust you to jump to such conclusions.

I feel the point was valid due to your history on such topics. You said what you said, no one forced you to say it. Surely you should have no problem with us commenting on it.