[Mystic Mock]

I mean no offence to Craig as he seems like a nice guy,but it was funny when he got lesser votes to stay than somebody thats only just returned to the comp in the last two weeks lol.

And Gary is a prick as Amelia killed Craig in the sing-off imo.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

I mean no offence to Craig as he seems like a nice guy,but it was funny when he got lesser votes to stay than somebody thats only just returned to the comp in the last two weeks lol.

And Gary is a prick as Amelia killed Craig in the sing-off imo.

I was stunned that Craig had fewer votes but I think Gary has missed a vital point, it is about the song choices too.Personally I think in the sing off, Craig performed his song correctly and with the right sensitivity whereas I feel Amelia overdid her song.

Craig was last night given the most dire and boring 'Bond' theme ever in my opinion, he was all over the place with it and it sounded bad, that's what the public voted on overnight,he has never been in the bottom 2.
So for me someone who had just come back and performed 2 weeks only, then was in the last 2 this week with someone who had never been in the bottom 2 all these weeks should never have stayed over him.

Gary though and his song choice yesterday was to blame for Craig going really,I do also doubt any judge expected Craig to have polled less votes than Amelia though.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I was stunned that Craig had fewer votes but I think Gary has missed a vital point, it is about the song choices too.Personally I think in the sing off, Craig performed his song correctly and with the right sensitivity whereas I feel Amelia overdid her song.

Craig was last night given the most dire and boring 'Bond' theme ever in my opinion, he was all over the place with it and it sounded bad, that's what the public voted on overnight,he has never been in the bottom 2.
So for me someone who had just come back and performed 2 weeks only, then was in the last 2 this week with someone who had never been in the bottom 2 all these weeks should never have stayed over him.

Gary though and his song choice yesterday was to blame for Craig going really,I do also doubt any judge expected Craig to have polled less votes than Amelia though.

I understand your point Joey and you do make some valid points,but as it was both there first time in the bottom two I just see it as fair enough,I also think its about personal preference aswell as I prefer Amelia to Craig where as I think you prefer Craig to Amelia dont you?

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

I understand your point Joey and you do make some valid points,but as it was both there first time in the bottom two I just see it as fair enough,I also think its about personal preference aswell as I prefer Amelia to Craig where as I think you prefer Craig to Amelia dont you?

This may sound a bit odd jf, I really liked Amelia when she was in the final 4, Craig has a good voice but somehow I didn't see him as a winner so rated Amelia better than him.

However,I personally don't think it was fair that anyone was brought back the way Amelia was, I don't think she should have a place now in the competition,it's not fair to the people who have performed all those other weeks.I would have said that no matter who had come back in.

So for that reason alone,unfairly or not,I would have rather Amelia gone home tonight.
It's academic because likely neither Craig or Amelia would have won this anyway,for me though Amelia is like an extra,(like a late entry housemate on BB) and unless someone has done the full stint in a programme I never support them to be winners.

I do like Amelia but she, like Craig, needs certain songs to really shine as well,she ain't getting them on the X Factor though,she was my 3rd least liked on Saturday only beating Misha and Craig in my opinion.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

This may sound a bit odd jf, I really liked Amelia when she was in the final 4, Craig has a good voice but somehow I didn't see him as a winner so rated Amelia better than him.

However,I personally don't think it was fair that anyone was brought back the way Amelia was, I don't think she should have a place now in the competition,it's not fair to the people who have performed all those other weeks.I would have said that no matter who had come back in.

So for that reason alone,unfairly or not,I would have rather Amelia gone home tonight.
It's academic because likely neither Craig or Amelia would have won this anyway,for me though Amelia is like an extra,(like a late entry housemate on BB) and unless someone has done the full stint in a programme I never support them to be winners.

I do like Amelia but she, like Craig, needs certain songs to really shine as well,she ain't getting them on the X Factor though,she was my 3rd least liked on Saturday only beating Misha and Craig in my opinion.

Fair enough Joey.